You are a Hawaiian living on Maui, one of the Hawaiian Islands, in 1890.
Your parents work in a sugar mill owned by American planters. Although
the mill supplies jobs, you don’t trust the sugar planters. They have
already made your king sign a treaty that gives them a lot of power in
the islands. You are afraid they will take over the government.
What would you do if planters took over your islands?
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
DeleteRubaiya 812 - If the planters took over my island i will have a war with them, and get my island and it is not their property. First of all i will kill them and i will take over their company and see how they feel!!! and if they win the war which they wont, because i will have the best army ever.
ReplyDeleteWell, I will have this thoughts in my mind but killing and fighting instead a way to solve the problem. I will try to fight to get my land back in another way.
DeleteRubaiya 812 - i meant i would win the war and take over their company and also convince the king not to take the island over by the planters.
DeleteBut, let think about it for a few second. The king already sign a treaty where the planters to own a lot of power, where will you get your reinforcements?
Deletei agree Hawaii was just a territorial island at that time so not much reinforcement to come to help you'll just be trapped or executed from the others.
Deletei don't think so this will cause many death and they have a king behind. -amy803
DeleteI don't think starting a war is a good idea since the planters have most of the power.
Deletei dont think starting a war is a good idea
DeleteExplain why you feel this way
DeleteIf planters took over my islands I will go to our king and convince him to stop the planters from taking over because the island does not belong to the planters.
ReplyDeletei disagree because the king is already going with the planters just like monopolies during the industrial age so they cant change their mind so we should protest.
DeleteI agree with Jackie , because the king will not listen to you, he want power
DeleteJIan 812
I agree with you Andy and would like to add that if the land isn't theirs they shouldn't be trying to take over.I also disagree with you because the king may not be the guy to ask to convince the planters from taking over because he may not be able to do it.
Delete----------------Marjona
But if we protest by ourselves there will be less of a percent of winning. Why not get ourselves more percent of winning then start protesting?
DeleteThat may not work
Deleteyou may try both protesting and more chance of winning
-----------Marjona
Protesting is like the way of fighting for your land. If your protest fail then I don't think you could get your land back anymore.
DeleteI agree and would like to add why not move to another place then? if the protest wont work?
DeleteWhat i would do is defend my island.Try to fight them and start a protest,take my land back.Natali812
ReplyDeletei would protest with other people.i will convince the powerful man and tell him to try to stop the planters. vanessavilchis812
ReplyDeleteNATALI812-i agree because they shouldnt take my land thats not there and i would have war and if i win would take their land.
DeleteRubaiya 812 - also they should respect our island if they are going to take over it and they cant make any changes to our island.
ReplyDeletei agree with andy because war and fighting is not the solution
ReplyDeleteWhy is it not the answer?
DeleteThe planter are gaining power so why just do strikes and riots like the time during the industrial period that would also get people to join in on your side to get the situation under control without tooo much violence.
ReplyDeleteYes, as I mention before, fighting and killing instead the best solution of the best. Maybe if you continue to advice your king, he might have some other ideas to save the island.
DeleteSince it isn't their property, I would fight for my land and see how they feel when I try to take over their company.
ReplyDelete------------------Marjona
How will you do so? It might be your land ,but there is YOUR king on THEIR side!
Deletei agree with you Marjona because to start of, it isnt the planters' land they dont rule it.the best reason not to start problems is to find their OWN country and start planting.....there no problems ..and if there land isnt good enough well sucks for them Alice 812
DeleteAndy Jiang------->
DeleteI would create my own war without asking the king even if he was on their side.I also would ask the people on the island for help!!!!!!!!
Alice- Yes the land can be your BUT the plant does not belong TO you
Deleteif the planters took over the island i would move out of my island,which is a very safe option or maybe start a real war.I would fight back for my own country and the place ive lived in.One reason why i said that i would move is because i might be weaker then the planters.the reason why i would start a WAR is because i do care about my OWN land
ReplyDeleteAlice 812
why not fight back and get your land you were there first
DeleteI agree with ermiyas because the land is yours, you were there first which you should be fighting for!!!!!
Delete-----------------Marjona
i dont wanna die Alice 812
DeleteIf planters took over my islands, I would fight against the planters and convince the king to fight them with me.
ReplyDelete---_________________________________JIan 812
i would try to take over the factory with a malita of my own cause we know that they will eventually take over the island with there evil ways
ReplyDeleteIf the planters take over my island i would beg the king to stop giving them power by taking everything away from the planters.If the king don't stop giving him power i will beat the planters down with my own power.
ReplyDeletetrue if king doesnt stop then burn down the planters farms and properties since we would be jobless once the king gives them power
Deletewhat i would if the planters took over my islands is that i would try really hard to get them back i woluld create a army group and try to get it back because the islands are ours not theres.they are just trying to get our islands while we are just working it isnt fair what i would if the planters took over my islands is that i would try really hard to get them back i woluld create a army group and try to get it back because the islands are ours not theres.they are just trying to get our islands while we are just working it isnt fair i would start a war to get it all back -.- -tammyfabara 812
ReplyDeleteGreetings fellow classmates, you asked for my response and here it is.
ReplyDeleteFirst things first, there's no such thing as "They take over my island", If I will own an island, then I will protect the island, put up wars to keep the island, and god knows what else. However, If "they did" , then I will try to manipulate them, by saying something like "I will give you the land without any wars. We can work for the land together without any problems and make the best out of it." I that doesn't work, I will constantly fight, If fighting didn't work out, then I will just give up, it's not the end of the world. I will move to another island.
~Aida Lebeb 812
yea but its your island you lived in it the reason why i would move is I DONT WANNA DIE i would fight over my my country alice 812
DeleteSINCE the the planters took over the island they could take over the government and could make the people work for them
ReplyDeleteJamal Mohammad 812
ReplyDeleteI would tell them to leave it alone and this is my property. Then their would be war if they dont listen. Ill start riots. Thats my territory. Im not giving up on the.I would tell them to leave it alone and this is my property. Then their would be war if they dont listen. Ill start riots. Thats my territory. Im not giving up on them.
i so AGREE with you
ReplyDelete-tammy 812
thanks, gorl, thanks `aida
Deleteif the planters keep planting stuff and keep taking over then there may be war but people might get scared to fight a war because the king is also be fighting with the planters
ReplyDeletethats is a good idea abdullah because violence can not solve.
Delete----jackie zhang
what are you agreeing to?
ReplyDeletejessica johnson -812
If the planters took over my island I would try to make a deal or something with them or like try to talk it out, if that didnt work out I would've fought for my island if it really meant something to me. But like war and violence isn't the solution, so it might not even solve the problem but might aswell give it a try. ashleyb
ReplyDelete-jane
ReplyDeletei will start a war and stop the planter from taking over my lands.i will go over to the king and convince him to stop the planter.
Rubaiya 812 - also they should respect our island if they are going to take over it and they cant make any changes to our island.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you, if they going to take over our land they should still respect our rules on how we like getting things done. They should be able to work cooperatively and listen to what we have to say.shahida 803
Deletewhat i would want do if planters took over my islands is i might leave or protest. -amy803
ReplyDeleteIf the planters take over my island then i would try to protest over it and go against the planters also try to stop them ....
ReplyDeleteFATEMA JAHAN LEEYA
803
If the planters took over my work island i most likely would protest against them because its mine or i would give up and leave.
ReplyDelete-jasmine 803
jingjingweng803 - i would try to fight back and don't let them to take my land.and tell king i was disagree to take my land
ReplyDeleteIf farmers took over my island, i would go to the king and tell him about what's happening and ask him if he could end the treaty and send the Americans back home. In case he refuses to do that,i might either leave the island and find somewhere else to live or just ignore them and live sadly in the island that's taken over by Americans.
ReplyDeleteif the planters take over my island i will try to protect the people who lives in my island, i'll go against them and try to stop them.
ReplyDeleteminha jinat khundkar 803
agree
DeleteI agree with you Minha, if they try to violate my people I would definitely try to protect them. ~shahida 803
DeleteI will be angry and i will fight because what if they didn't say to me that the planters will go and take over my lands; or a bit happy if they will plant in my land and they will give at least 5% of their crops.
ReplyDeleteif the planters take my land,i will try to make a group of peaple and fight with them and try to get them of my land . mostafa said 803
ReplyDeleteI agree with you bcuz i will make a group of people too and i forgot to put make group of people to fight in my answer
Deletesaid , i agree with you . because If they took your island, you will not have sugar mill work, maybe you work for them
DeleteAgree,Because the island is ours.
Delete-lululiu803
If they took over my land I will make group of people and against it.
ReplyDeleteI would reject their condition, will try to fight back
ReplyDeletetian yu wu 803
i agree. Because the land in the began was mine and then take it it very angry - jingjingweng803
Deletei would protest to stop! i would watch them to scare them.
ReplyDeleteIf planters took over my islands then I would probably protest against them only if they were to do something (Stupid) against us.
ReplyDeletei would too ~shahida 803
DeleteIf they took my island, I will fight to get back my island, they don't have right to take it.
ReplyDeleteJensen Cai 803
I wil start off with a warning. If that didnt work then i will be more agressive and violent. If that didnt work either i will try to convince the king to help me get rid of them. yongqichen803
ReplyDeleteIf they try to took my island.Then I will go to the any type of headman who has power and I will ask for help.If they don't help me then I will make a group and protest for the right and to make a new law for land.
ReplyDeleteREDOANUL SAHAT 803
I f planters tie to take over my land, I would limit the amount of power they have if it isn't fair or just plain cruel. If they were to take over the government then I would do the same thing;don't make unreasonable choice and don;t my voice in the government. ~shahida 803
ReplyDeleteI would lock them in one place to make them pay for all they have done
ReplyDeletesteven cai 803
IF MY ISLAND WAS TRYING TO GET TAKEN ILL GO TO ANY HEADMAN AND CRY FOR HELP TBH
ReplyDeleteashraf
ReplyDeleteIf my island is gonna be taking over . i will have a war with them and do everything i could to win it .
ReplyDeletebut the side u fighting i has too much people ---
DeleteIf they are trying to take over my land . i will go and ask for help . if no one is helping i will have a fight with them.if this dosent work i will do the same thing as what they do to me .
ReplyDeleteI agree with ChengJi Wang ,because he trying to taking the land over . He try to save he own land
DeleteIF PLANTER TOOK OVER YOUR ISLAND, I WILL PROTEST AND CONVINCE THEM- JZ 814
ReplyDeletei agree with you that we can convince them.
Deletei disagree since it might not work. they might not be so easy to persaade and you need a group of people. plus they might be afraid to go against thoise planter
DeleteI will be took the Island back from they . Then to safe the land for my-self.I should be protect the land, not be get the other person .....
ReplyDeleteIf planters took over your islands , i will protest and convince other people to agree with me . Also i will find some powerful man and let them help us .
ReplyDeletei agree because the powerful men might convince them and help get the land back.
DeleteI agree with Mengjia, because the island is one's thing, no one have right to get them.
DeleteIf the planters took over my island we will send spies to sneak into where the planters keep the treaty and destroy it so that they will have no more power.Then, we would be able to fight back.
ReplyDeletei agree because then the planters wont have any power and the otherside will be in more control and let us get our land back .
Deletei agree with u that if u destroy the treaty they wouldnt have any more power
Deleteif planter took over my island,i will go to king and persuade him stop giving planter the power and stop the planter since its my island not their
ReplyDeletei agree with you that we can persuade the king to stop them
Deleteif the planter take over the island i would create a group of people taht agree with me and try to take over the island myself. this is beacuse icen i don't trust them i'm pretty sure i wouold not like there rule
ReplyDeleteif the planters took over my island then i would have a protest and make up groups to make my side stronger. i would try to explain to them what they are doing is wrong and if they do not agree and get violent i would make a compromise.
ReplyDeleteIf they take over my island i will destroy them one by one so they will not be able to fight back . then i will take back my island.
ReplyDeletejose 814;if the planters took over my islands i will declare war and make them pay for stealing my islands.also i would make a big wall around my island so that when other people try to come in they can not get in because its fully protected by my wall and no enemies could attack me or my island
ReplyDeleteIf planter took over my island, I will fight back, nobody want lose them own things, I have my right to get my own thing back, and use anything I could use to win.
ReplyDeleteI agree with wei because I got the same opinion as wei.
Deletei agree with you in some point but i think end the problem with peace is a better way
DeleteLewis Tang 814
ReplyDeleteIf the planters are taking over my island, then I will have protests and if that doesn't work, I'll just start war and hopefully win. To begin with they don't even have possession on my island so it isn't fair.
If the planter takes over the island and control the government system, I would most likely protest until the government had got convince to not let the planters to get control over the island and the government system. Also I would stay within the island no matter if the planters had control over the island and fight for my rights and opinion.
ReplyDeleteFengLin Chen 814
ReplyDeleteIf planters took over my islands i would convince the king to fight back, at least let them pay for what hey have done.
if the planters are taking over my island ,i would protest and go against the sugar planter.also i will write a letter to the king to take away the power of that sugar plants.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you because there are several ways to protest which includes protest. -Dustin Ni 814
DeleteI agree with u because I would do the same thing as u
Deleteif planters took over my island then i will convince other people to help me fight back and protest.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you, because we can do what we can to get our island back.
DeleteYingshu Chen 814
ReplyDeleteIf planter took over my island , I will convince other people to help me protect my island and and take my island back.
If the planters took over my island, I would consider a peace conversaion with them at first. Then, if it does not work, I would destroy the treaty that singed between our king and the whites. Next, I would send spies that give me information about them while I design a long-term war plan of fighting back my land.
ReplyDeleteShahria 814- If the planters took over the island, I would declare war and i would want to make a treaty. I would bring up people in this situation. If the police dont take care of it, I would take matter with my own hands. I would give them warnings before all this of course, because then it would be just plain cruel.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you
DeleteIf they are going to try to taking over my island I would protest with people who agrees with me and fight back until I get my land back
ReplyDeleteI AGREE WITH YOU BECAUSE PROTESTING CAN BEAT THE OPPONENT DOWN '-'
DeleteIf the planters take over the island, then I will ask them to give us the same life we have before. If they say no, then I will tell every how bad the island will be if the planter took over the land, and tell everyone to pack their stuff up, and leave the island to other place.
ReplyDeleteXueRu Lin-814
If the planters took over my island, I would protest, if thats not going to be a solution then I would probably start a war and fight the island back.I would also convince the people with power so they can help solve the problem together.-Dustin Ni 814
ReplyDeletei would defend the island i lived for a long time., i would also work there with my family. if they try to take over the island i would kill them. somtimes violence is needed to protect what is special to you and everyone else. it is no good if they take it over because more people that lived on the island would suffer. ~jordan 814
ReplyDeleteIf the sugar planters are going to take over my island , first I will tell the government what going to happen so they can prepare if it really going to happen . Next I will tell the king so he can change the amount of powers the planters had or else we are going under the control of the planters . I also going to team up with other protesters so we can beat the planters down . If the following above does not work , we will start a war to stop them from taking the government powers
ReplyDeleteif the planters take over the island i would protest. also i would probably leave the country but before that i would try to change the fact that the planters would try to take over the government. i would hold town meetings and would hold gatherings and try to gain followers so that the planters would not take over the government because i believe that they would do very bad things to the people- benjamin 814
ReplyDeleteIf people take over my island, I would want to declare war with them. The winning side will take control of the island.
ReplyDeleteAkmal13- I agree with you because i will be angry somebody takes over my land i will also will make a war with them.
DeleteI agree with u because I think it's a good agreement.Who ever win's will control the island. BY: SUMIYA , MAYNA 813
DeleteIf the planter take over the island I would try to send a letter to the king and telling him that our island was been taken over. Also get spies to get the evidences that the planter are taking over the island. Give the evidences to the king and get support from other countries and get our island back.
ReplyDelete.I agree with you,because if we get evidences that the planters are taking over the island ,maybe the king will stand on our side and help us.
DeleteIf the planters take over the island,I will protest before I protest I will talk to other people that live on the island and let other people agree with me and we protest together.
ReplyDeleteIf planters take over my island i would have to declare a war and the strongest side will get the control of the island.chenxushi813
ReplyDeleteif planters took over the islands i would go war with them and if they lose i will make them my slave XD
ReplyDeleteif people are taking over my island,I will be angry and I will fight back and I would protect it.And I would try to convince them to leave if not then I will fight.by:jiaweiliu class:813
ReplyDeleteIf the planters took over my island , I will protest against it . If that doesn't work than I would like to start war , and convince others to join the war .So we can take back our island.
ReplyDeleteBY: SUMIYA , MAYNA 81
(Habiba Sheikh) I agree with you because i would tell all the workers to protest.
DeleteI agree with you because you have worked so hard to grow the stuff and now planters want to take over your land which is very angry because you worked hard and now they just want it and you will not able to make money so you should convince other to declare war with them to gain your land back , and the winning side will take control of the land.
Delete-Abubakr Kahorov 813
If the planters want to take over the island then I will choose to protect this island from the planters that will come to take the island I will try to ask the goverment for backup if this dont work I will then have to have a meeting to get ideas of what should we do to get the planters off this island if that dont work then we can set traps to make them sceard so that they will neaver come back to this island but it all of this dont work I will have to use the last resort which is to fight to get them off this island.
ReplyDelete(Habiba Sheikh) I would protest and tell all the workers to go on strike. I would do anything in my power to get my point across. If we had someone who is wealthy on our side then i would help them with speeches. This is what i would do if planters took over your islands.
ReplyDeleteIf the planters took over our islands then I will getting the people all together to form union to fight against the planters. -ShiYao Chen 813
ReplyDeleteI would protest and strike. These methods are peaceful but they still get the point across. Starting a war or rioting will just cause blood shed. Also the government is omnipotent compared to me so having more people on my side will dwindle the power of the government.
ReplyDeleteIan 813: Being that i'm nobody compared to all this authority I would take my belongings and go somewhere where i can live in peace instead of trying to retaliate.
ReplyDeleteIf the planters would take my land i would declare war with them . The winning side will get the land and take control over it
ReplyDelete-Abubakr Kahorov 813
If the planters took over my islands then I will fight for my land and I would protest, find a group of people to create a group of power and fight for. I will also send a letter to king. (Na 813 )
ReplyDeletei AGREE with u
Deleteif they take over the island ,then me and my people will have a war with them and take back my island
ReplyDeleteIf they will take over my land, I would do nothing, or try to.I have no power to go against them. They're about to take the king down.Same thing Americans did to Native Americans.Stay on their land for a while, and say" nope, your land is ours" If they will try to go against US, it will end with war, and no one wants it.So the best way to be puppy, and hope for the best.
ReplyDeleteIf the planters take the land I will tell king to kill them if they don't give us the land
ReplyDeleteThey are about to depose the king. He is just a puppet.
Deletefurqan ali 813 I will fight with them and if they have more people then us. we will protest and call other countries for help.
ReplyDeleteIf they take over my island, i might just start a war with them. cause if you just talk or speak to them it wouldn't work....and they will know your weakness.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Na from 813, because we are living in the island and i wont let it happen. i will bring other people who thinks its wrong and fight for our home, the next thing i would do is go to the president and talk about it.
ReplyDeletei would try my hardest to keep the islands and fight to keep my own government and land. Also i would fight the sugar mill and would do all in my power to keep everything the way it was
ReplyDeletewell being friendly and protest peacefully wouldnt really work since they took over our islands without asking us or anything so i would have a plan to take our island back with a covert attack on the kings place and the troops that would be there and start a war
ReplyDeletei would do all in my power to stop them from doing anything to property that belongs to hawaians
Delete(samiha akter 811) i agree because i would have done the same thing in order for my land to be mine and stay mine.
Delete(Atifah Osrat- 81) I agree with you when you say that protesting peacefully wouldn't work so I would also go all in when it comes to protesting
Delete(samiha akter 811) i would protest and fight for my land. i would not let the planters take over a land that belongs to me. i would also get others to help me fight and tell the workers to go on strike.
ReplyDelete(Atifah Osrat- 811) I agree with you but I would also try sending a letter to the King
DeleteWhat i would do when they take over my island is to start a war.I would start a war because its my land and we spend so much time on it for working day and night to support our own children's.
ReplyDeleteWork with Tony Pan and Tony Zou
Delete(Atifah Osrat 811) If planters took over the island I was living in, I would fight them off but knowing that I can't do that alone, I would probably gather a group and protest. If it goes out of hand and they completely ignore our protests, than I would make the group grow bigger and try to call other countries for help. Along with this, I would send a letter to the King.
ReplyDeleteI well start a war with them, and i won't let them take my land.
ReplyDeleteit me AVAZJON ASLAMOV
Deletei do not think that starting a war is a good idea for the king
ReplyDeleteI will gather up my people and atake if they ever atake on us.
ReplyDeletejessie zou 811
i would have rebel and lead a rebalian to get the planters to leave our island alone.
ReplyDeletei AGREE! feezan811
Deletei agree with you because the planters would most likely not care since they have all the power now instead of the king
Deleteif the planters took over the island that i was located in i would fight them off with my neighbors that lived with me i would protest and one by one slay them all feezan 811
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteit will not be acceptable, i wont allow for all the development of island. I worked hard for it i will receive it. -Xavier 811
ReplyDeleteif they just came to take over to take over our land and make us work with low wages the villagers would get together and fight back aganist the invaders. Marco 811
ReplyDeleteI would do anything to try an control these farmers to try and get them off my island
ReplyDeleteI would try to start a riot along with many people to try to have the king's attention, so he will listen.
ReplyDeleteJason Garcia-811
-Mena Sabeha 811- If planters took over my land, i would start a fight with them because its my property. I would start a war with them because that's my home and its also a home to many people too. They're not allowed to take over other people's land because they don't have the right to do that.
ReplyDeleteif it was my land then id set a protest and if that doesnt work then ill burn their stuff
ReplyDelete