Andrew Carnegie made a fortune in the steel industry and went on to give a good deal of it away. In an 1889 speech, "The Gospel of Wealth," Carnegie proclaimed that the rich had a responsibility to use their money to help others. He said, "The man who dies . . . rich dies disgraced."
Do you agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others? Explain your reasons. If you had millions of dollars, what would you do with it? Would you feel you should help others less fortunate than you? Give reasons for your answer
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Deleteabdullahbinomar In an 1889 speech, "The Gospel of Wealth," Carnegie proclaimed that the rich had a responsibility to use their money to help others. He said, "The man who dies . . . rich dies disgraced."r812
ReplyDeleteDoesnt explain what u think
DeleteAbdullah your response to the question needs be more than just merely repeating the question put in front of you. You need to formulate and opinion on the subject and back it up with specific facts.
DeleteI agree with carnegie because if you have alot of money you should be using it for useful reasons instead of using it for stuff that doesn't matter, but anyway theres a difference between being rich and being wealthy, so if you're rich you're gonna use up all your money one day, so wealthy people should be helping people because they're gonna have money all their life. Rich people or wealthy people get more respect then the poor people and the middle class people, they should be donating and helping people. If I had millions of dollars I would help people because I don't like seeing less fortunate people struggling, plus I see homeless people everywhere I go now, but some of the homeless people have places to stay and they just use their money for drugs so I'd be specific of who I'd pick to help. - VIA ASHLEYYYYYYYY
ReplyDeleteI agree with the statement you mention because apparently if you have the money you will use the money anyway. Donating money to the person in need worth it than using it all by yourself.
Deletei agree because if you only use your money for yourself, then it's like using money for only one person and it means you're not helping others.it'll be a pleasure to help others
Deletei agree because you should use your money in good causes rather than using it in things that are not necessary.
Deleteyes i do beleive that the richer people should have an obligation to help the poorer people so everything can be equal and you dont have to worry about alot of people dying
ReplyDeletejessica 812
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Deletereally -.-
Deletejessicaaaaaa
yeahhh buddy - ashley
Deletei agree with Carnegie because if you have millions of dollars you would like someone in need put yourself in there shoes what if you didn't have money you would like for them to help you . wouldn't you? if i had millions of money i would love to go to my country and help those kids who need clothes and food! the reason i would help is because if one day i become poor with no money i would like someone to help. also because im caring
ReplyDeletei agree wit u kinda i guess, but if you got money and then you spend it all on poor ppl then u get broke , they aint gonna help you
Delete+jessie
i agree with you bc thats the right thing to do instead of using it for useless things . - ashley
Deletei agree carneige was saying right because eif you have so much money and you do not use it in a good cause you will die in guilt. also you should help the poor so they can be capable of doing something and maybe helpful to the world.
DeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich have an responsibility to help others. Rich can help people and give people the benefit of life. If I had millions of dollars I will kept some for myself and donate the rest of the money to the people in need of them. I feel I should help others that have less money because using the money wisely can make you a better person -Andy Jiang (812)
ReplyDeleteI agree with you, money is for everyone in the world not just for the rich. Middle class or rich people should take responsibility to donate some of their money to the less fortunate bacause they are like all of us.
DeleteI agree with you, if someone have money that can use for helping others, they should help them.
Deletei agree because to treat each other fairly( like every teacher is saying they are doing) u guys should live the same way and people will be treated the same because someone might be bullied for being poor or brag because they are to rich.
DeleteI agree with Carnegie because the rich people are wealthy and they should share it to the world, selfishness and greediness is bad. If I had one million dollars I would share it with the world or something that can be beneficial and giving them to schools, helping lower class people get an education.
ReplyDeleteSelfishness and greediness is bad and I agree with the advise of sharing the money with public. People are people, everyone should be born equally. Children born in a poor family also should have the right of getting education.
Deletei agree because everyone deserves an education and it would be a good ides to help people educate so they can do something for themselves and no longer stay poor.
Deleteselfishness and greediness is bad but giving to education instead of helping poor people survive from starvation......
Deletetammy 812.
ReplyDeletei agree with carnegie that the rich have the obligation to help others because first of all other people arent rich they dont have food or even a house.And if i ad millions of doallrs i would donate money to the poor.Yes i would help others less fortunate than me because other people need food and water and clothing and a house and i would feel good about myself.
(samiha 811)
Deletei agree with you because poor people have lack of supplies
Yes i agree with Carnegie because its not fair how the rich have all this money and not do anything with it or spend it on worthless things. If i had a million of dollars I would give to the less fortune because there's alot of money that i would probably have left after I spend it and it wouldn't hurt to give some money to people who really need it.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you because even if spending all that money for yourself, you would have some leftovers that you probably don't really know what else to do with it after you have everything you already needed. It would really help the poor people a lot because they also dream of having stuff they don't have.
DeleteMarjona 812
i feel that Carnegie was a very generous man but i would leave my money to my kids i would probably start a business that built machines for the future or to find a cure for hazard's disease
ReplyDeleteJamal Mohammad 812- I agree with Carnegie because back then people starved and didnt have a lot of money. If you do good deeds they'll come back to you. Money was a small thing back then there were poor people and wealthy people. If you had a lot of money it wont hurt if you help someone out who really needs your help.
ReplyDeletepreachhh, if you do good deeds it'll award youuuuu in the futuree. - ashleyy
DeleteThat is a good idea..
DeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others.First, if the rich person helps the people that needs money more, he should give it to the people that really needs it.If I had millions of dollars, I would help out the people that is needed like when they are really poor and needs some food or drink.I would help them out because even if I had all that money for myself, it wouldn't do any good like the nation.
ReplyDeleteMarjona 812
Osvaldo class 812
ReplyDeleteYes I believe that rich people may help the poor people so everything could be equal. So no one could worry about that people are dying, So they could be a lot of people being alive
i kinda agree with that but their own family kind should help each other and others to help that person. its not be to keep people alive because people die of other health problems. so u just ting about that.
DeleteVanessa 812- i disagree because its your money and you could do anything with it they probably lost their money.if i had millions of dollars i would help give some money but not like to the whole city.its not going to be like back in the days where you were abligated to help!i would feel happy helping other people less fortunate because they get to have food and cloths
ReplyDeletetrue, its not like their obligated to do that, but thats the right thing to do if you have alot of money. - ashley
DeleteNo i don't agree because you should help the poor and the weak people so they can live on,everyone should have the right to live freely and happily .If i have millions of dollars i would get a house .I feel i should help others that have less money because they have a poor family and they won't last for long.(No no estoy de acuerdo, porque usted debe ayudar a los pobres y los débiles para que puedan vivir, todo el mundo debería tener el derecho a vivir libremente y felizmente .Si tengo millones de dólares que obtendría una casa .I siento que debo ayudar otros que tienen menos dinero porque tienen una familia pobre y no van a durar por mucho tiempo .)~Alex Lei~812
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help other,because if rich help other people ,then when rich people become poor people.They will get help from the people they help before.
ReplyDeleteIf I had millions of dollars,I would deposit the money in the bank account.
Jian 812
i agree with u but when u become poor then the other rich people would not give u anything because most rich people are greedy and the moment they see money they keep it all to themselves
DeleteAlice- Jackie Zhang i agree with you,beacause all the poor people were given money by rich people and if the rich people did not give money to the poor people then that is counted selfish although poor people could spend there money to risk there winning but other then that,rich peoplr should not be selfish
ReplyDeleteRubaiya 812 - I disagree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others. Because some people have families to help too. And it's basically on their decision, and it's part of their lives. If i ever had millions of dollars , what i would do with it is give some money to charities, and build a new hospitals ,and help my families. And save money for the future. I would help other people, because would make me happy and others happy :) .
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThe reason why its an obligation that rich people help the less fortune because the rich people spend money on junk and not help people.If i had money i would help the ones in need and and help their in the needs.The reason why i would help because the less needed dont have enough money to help their family or there self.
ReplyDelete812 NATALI
This is a good starting point but you need get a little deeper in the issue.... Explain what you think people's needs are... much like our discussion about need vs. want in class...
Deletei desagree with ....
ReplyDeleteWhy??
DeleteI agree with Carnegie to help them. If you have millions of dollars , give people who are on the streets that need something.Like if they are hungry you would not be like who cares just the give them money.Also,when they are cold, buy them expensive jacket to stay with them. Aola Abouhajj 812
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletei agree with Carmegie that the rich have the responsibility to help the poor. If i have a million dollars i will keep 3/4 to myself and 1/4 to help the people who need it- jane chen 812
ReplyDeletei agree with Carnegie because he had a lot of money and it is his responsibility to pay the poor because how wealthy he was not to be selfish also before his death he didnt know what to do with his money. if i were him i will spend money on car and house.
ReplyDelete******Alice 812
i agree with u!!!
Deletei do agree with carnige because if you only keep the money and don't help others then the money will only fly away after other things such as death. why not help others? what'll i'll do is to help others because if i die with all the money, the money will go with you and have no use, why not help others?
ReplyDeleteI disagree with Carnegie that the rich have a choice to help others. Because some people have families to help others.But I also agree wit carnegie because he is wise to give to others
ReplyDeleteI strongly agree with you because I won't give my money to anyone! All those people who says agree are all faking themselves
Deletei agree with Andrew Carnegie because if you have a lot of money share it with the people who is poor if you have a lot of money and you died you don't bring the money when you died. And i will invest the 1/4 of my whole money to business that can help people in their lives like transportation and cheaper foods.
ReplyDeleteagree !!!!
DeleteWhy do you agree? EXPLAIN
Deletei agree with carnegie because what i would do with that kind of money is to make it useful to help the poor,buy the, things they need to live, to make them happy.even give money away because your showing that u care for others and not just yourself.
ReplyDeleteI agree because if the rich has some money he doesn't need instead of spending it on junk he can give it to poor people who desperately need that money.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you because if you have enough money you should have some have some heart and give some money to people that need
Deletei agree for give money to help people. because people they need the money beut cannot work for health problem that can help it and if i have those money that i will buy the house and car... - JINGJINGWENG 803
ReplyDeleteyou will buy the house and car? OMG , You should help the poor, should not be so selfish
Deletenmb tiangou u enough
Deletewho is tiangou . IDK
Deletei know u
Deletewho ,what is tiangou mean
DeleteRachel 803
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others because they are the people that have and make to money. To add on, they don't only make money but they make a great amount of money to help at least one person. If I had millions of dollars, I would give half of my money to the less fortunate than myself because most the rich had died with money still in their banks. On the other hand, the poor had die before their time due lack of supplies (no money or lack of money caused this) or natural causes.
i agree with carnegie because If I had the money, I help those poor people, give them supplies to help them live
ReplyDelete- zhen xuan pan
Deleteagree or not
Delete养小三么hhhhh
Deletemostafa 803
ReplyDeleteI agree with canegie because he is so rich he can help the poor peaple also he can solve the problems that they have .if i have a million doller i well mak a schools and hospitals for the poor peaple
I agree with Carnegie because if I'm die no one will take my money and that is not do any good to me. If I had millions of dollars I will give someone very poor or else it just can be dirt when I dead
ReplyDeletezhi cheng zhang 803
steven cai 803
ReplyDeleteI agree that the rich help others with their money. the reason is because
steven cai 803
I agree with Carnegie that the rich help others with their money. the reason is because the rich can do anything with money. If I had a million dollars, the first thing I would do is donate half of the dollar to the poor. I would feel good to help those less fortunate than me.
I agree with Carnegie because if anyone have a lot of money then that parson can help other because that person do not need those money.If I had millions of dollar then I would invest those money in a business or gave it to my family members.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie that rich people does have an obligation to help others because it's the right thing to do. Like my mother always says, "Treat others the way you want to be treated.'' If you help others, they will treat you with a whole lot of respect but if you don't, then you'll be treated like garbage.
ReplyDeleteI had millions of dollars, I would help find the cure for cancer and I'll help end world hunger.I feel that I should help other people that are because I know that if I were in their shoes I would someone to help me.
I do agree with Andrew C.saying because the rich should give back to the poor. If you are rich you should be ale to give back to the poor. When you die all that money got to go somewhere and you should give it for a good cause so you know you've done something extra good with your life. I would do the same. ~shahida
ReplyDeleteIsrat Banna - 803
ReplyDeleteI am agree with carnegie that the rich an obligation to help other because, instead of wasting the money is good to help other people who don't have money,so they can use the money for a good reasons and they will be happy and they will pray for you. If I had millions of money, I would help poor people. I would give some money to charity because, it will make them happy, people who are orphan, that will make me happy.
I agree with you by helping poor people you can save many lives
DeleteBenjamin-i agree with Andrew Carnegie because you should not keep all the money to yourself. Helping others is always a good thing to do. if you are rich than u should try to spread the wealth for not only yourself and your family but with the people living in poverty. If i had millions of dollars i would first spend it on a house and car for my family then i would buy things my family and i want. Then i would start my own charity and donate to other charities.
ReplyDeleteI agree because that will save a lot of lives
DeleteShahria- I AGREE WITH Benjamin and Andrew Carnegie because you should not be greedy and share your money. Help your families and friends with the great amount of money you have.Donate to charities and help the needy.IF i had millions of dollars, I would spend it on myself and also my family. I would not be selfish with my money.
Deletei agree with benjamin, shahria ,and jian chen because you shouldnt be greedy and share your money with your friends and if they need it for an emergency give it to them and they wiil thank you and give it back to you.
DeleteI think rich people don't necessary need to help those who are poor . It depends on if they are generous enough and want to help others. So of course if rich people can help others out is very nice.If I have millions of dollars, I will donate them to people who need it to survive because life isn't easy and we should help each other if we can.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with you because if you have that such ability, you should something good for society.
DeleteI agree with you because rich people think they don't have a lot of money as other so they won't help those who are poor. They don't even know who is poor
DeleteI STRONGLY AGREE WITH YOU! ALSO, I'M THOSE PEOPLE THAT WON'T GIVE MONEY TO ANYONE! AHAHHAHAH
Deletei agree with with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others because since the rich are fortunate for making money they should help others. they should not have so much money before the die because that is greed.if i had a million dollars i would give 1/3 of it to the poor as charity. also with the rest of the money i would do something good for the world and not waste it on useless things.i would help people who are less fortunate then me because i would want them to do something good for themselves and be happy. also i would find them a job so they are fortunate again.
ReplyDeleteI have the same point of view.
DeleteI agree with Carnegie because the rich people should use their wealth for good causes. If i had a million dollars I would give part of my fortune to charity. I would give some of my money away because its a good feeling to have knowing u helped at least one person in the world to have a better life.
ReplyDeletei agree with you beause seeing other people happy can also make yourself happy. once you have helped someone, you will feel good because you know you made an impact on someones life.
Deletei agree with carnegie that rich should help other people. you are wasting the money that u had . if i would have millions of dollors i will buy 2 pool one for washing face one for washing feet. i would give charity my money because i likes to share with other people.
ReplyDeletei agree with you because help other is a very kind and nice thing to do
DeleteDon't pretend to be nice! You guys are all evil.
Deletei agree with the quote since you have so much money but you don't care for others so you are sefish. if i have millions of dollar i will give it to other since then i will look nice and i have no use for the money
ReplyDeleteDustin Ni- 814 I agree with you because you dont need that much money and you dont need that much so helping others isnt a problem'
DeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others, because it will help the poor people to be wealthy. It give them chances to live. If I have a millions of dollar, I will donate half of it to the poor people and half of it I will keep it to myself. I will feel happy of what I did to the poor people because they will be happy as well as myself.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you because you are so generous to help other even you have so much money
DeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others because we are all human beings that live on earth and as the same kind we should help each other and care for each other to make the world a better society. If I become rich I would spend some money on my families and friend to make their lives better too. On other other hand I would also help the homeless and improve there live style. Since sharing is caring.
ReplyDeletei agree with carnegie that rich people should try to help other people. if i would have millions of money i would choose to build a company and make more money to make people think i am the richest man in this world. i would give charity my money because a little money that could make the world better is not bad!
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie because we're all human and we need to help each other and using the extra money on things we don't need instead of helping the poor is considered selfish. If I had millions of dollars, I would share the money to those who need it to survive such as food and a house instead of using it for accessories and decorations.
ReplyDeleteFengLin Chen 814
ReplyDeleteYes I agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others because if you're rich you should help others. If I had millions of dollars, I would spend money on things I want to get. I would feel that I should help others that's less fortunate than me because they need help to be able to be success at their business.
i agree with you that you should help other and push them to the way of success.---gaoyuting
DeleteI agree with you because if other did not help you , you won't get that success at your business.
DeleteI disagreed with you! Because! Think about it, if those poor take our money and becomes more richer than us! And they are more powerful than us! And they will beat us up! What would you feel! So, don't give them the money!
DeleteI think rich people doesnt necessary need to help other .its depended on how they decided. If i had millions of dollars,first i would buy house for parent and some other things Also i would feel i should help others that was less fortunate than me ,because i know how life isnt easy than how we think so if you help other you would get something good return back to you.
ReplyDelete-------gao,yuting814
Dustin Ni - 814
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich people have an obligation to help people because if you have a million dollars, what's the point of wasting all for yourself? The rich should help the poors on what they need and it won't impact them that much. If you have a lot of money, it's good to help others since they live in the same community but much worse conditions.If I have a million dollars, I would help donate money to those who needs help and help others with their needs. I think I help others less fortunate than you since it doesnt impact me that much and its nice to help others and you may get good things back.
I disagree with you because "what's the point of wasting all for yourself?" isn't true because it's not wasting money since it's all yours and you can use that money for whatever you want.
DeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich an obligation to help poor peoples because, there are many people and children who is suffering from hunger and there are some rich people who are throwing their foods away... so if they help the poor people then the poor can survive they don't have to die from not having place to live and no food and no money. If I had millions of dollars, i would use it to help poor people because, it will make them happy so which make me happy too. Also, I would help them because it could save some people from dying.
ReplyDeletei think rich people have an obligation to help the people less fortunate than them. they should because they the less fortunate might not have a place to live or have any parents to take care of them and they could die.if i had a million dollars i would help the less forunate because i dont like seeing people out on the street.it also makes me feel bad to see people not take care of the less fortunate and just leave them be without helping them. if i were to be living on my own i would probably allowed them to go to my house and stay there. it will less the suffering of one person. if there is more than one i would probably help them all instead of just helping on because they had a much harder life than i had. me helping someone just makes me feel more better than not giving any to the less fortunate. it just feels like the right thing to do than keeping all the money to yourself.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie because when you get a lot of money ,that is not all own by you . Other had been help you work to earn that much money . So , when you become rich , you should give part of money to help others . If i had millions of dollars , i will use part of money for use in life , part of money for invest , and rest of money use to help others .
ReplyDeleteGOOD IDEA!!!!!!
DeleteI agree with Andrew Carnegie that rich people should use their money to help other,because sharing is caring. Humans and humans are family , they should help poor others and some rich people just born in rich family but some not , they were born in poor families, which make they life hard. So rich people should help poor peoples not giving all moneys to other, but help the and support them. If I have a million dollar, I would use these money to support poor peoples and help them. but at least I will save some money for my self.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others like the poor people ,that because they won't able to live if they don't have money [they can't buy foods, shelters, and clothing] these are the things they need in order to survive. If I have lot of money, I will give it to the poor people ,so they can live .
ReplyDeleteI WANT TO ADD ON THAT ALSO U CAN SAVE SOME MONEY FOR YOUR SELF SO YOU WONT BECOME POOR AS OTHERS
DeleteI agree with carnegie that rich people have to help the poor because we should provide love to everyone , if i have millions of money i would buy 2 cake , first one i will eat it in your face . second one u will look and i eat . i would give money to the people that have less money than me .
ReplyDeleteagree with carnegie that the rich should obligate into helping others. what is the point of having so much money without being to spend it out, might as well use it to help others. the more that is fortunate the better the world. letting yourself be the only fortunate one and still wanting more is pure greed and selfisness. if i had a million dollars i would use it to support others as well, if i already have a roof above my head and food to eat than what is the point of getting more all for myself, others should feel the same way i do.
ReplyDeletei agree with Carnegie because he use his wealth to help and change others life.
ReplyDeleteif i have so much money i will give a half of my money to helping poor people because i want to help others and i also need to save some money to myself.
I agree with Carnegie, the rich people should need help others, poor people have not enough money to have a good life, so rich people need to help them to get a better life. If I have million dollars, sure, I cannot get poor people all of this money, but, I will give out some of this money, because they have a hard life, so I have to have help them, on other hand, I should leaf some of money, cause I need live too.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with you! First of all, those poor people are so bad! They just sit there doing nothing and want us, the rich people, to give them money! That's not fair! So we shouldn't give them the money!
DeleteI agree with Carnegie that rich have an obligation to others who don't have such fortunate like you. For instance, people who have disability cannot do things that normal people can do. Also, sharing your wealth with others can fulfill your heart with jubilation. If I have millions of dollar, I will give part of my money to charity because they can use the money to cure many people. Also, I will give my money to orphanage because nobody can take care of them as they're at age of 18. So, they can use these money to achieve their goals for future.
ReplyDeletei agree with you because you should think about others and not your self
Deletei agree with with carnegie that rich people have to help the poor people because they not have money to buy thing . If i have millions dollar to buy something,first i will buy a house to live with my family.i will get money to poor people~ i will happy for get the farmer money ,they will happy too
ReplyDeleteYingshu Chen 814
ReplyDeleteI agreed with Andrew Carnegie because if we have that much money we should spend some on others instead of spending it all on our self. If we help others they might help us in the future when we have a difficult situation.
I agree with carnegie because when you are poor others help you so when we are rich we should also help them. Also not all the money you earn are make by your self part of it are olso others.if i have million of dollars i will use half of my money to help others because some of them help me to get rich and i want to make them having a better life.also,sharing is caring.
ReplyDeleteI agree with u
DeleteI agree with you because people should help out each.
DeleteI disagree with you QAQ because I know you won't give the money to the poor, you're just faking your self. Also, the poor people doesn't deserve our money! They should earn it by their self!
DeleteTing,I agree with you people people should help your self out
DeleteI think I should help people because I have a lot of money.And there is lots of people out there that needs help.
ReplyDelete(Habiba 813) i agree with you because people really do need help in this world.
DeleteI agree with Carnegie,because almost all rich people didn't care about poor people and think they were different from them and they were dirty. But rich people should care about poor people.If I have lot of money I will give some to poor people because these people need help and I will get something back from them if I help them.
ReplyDeletei agree because if you were the poor people then rich people didn't help you what will you feel so i think we need to help them.if i have million of dollars ,i will give half to the poor people all around because they need money which is to made their life better . by:jia wei liu
ReplyDeleteI disagree with Carnegie because it's not fair that I give my hard-earned money to those non fortune people. They should work hard their self, and try to earn the money. If I have million of dollars I must had work very hard. So I won't give my hard-earned money to others. They should work by their self. By the way, I am a selfish people QAQ
ReplyDeletein some point, I am agree with you because people should work for themselves.
DeleteI agree with carnegie, because when you are poor others people would help you.So when we are rich we should also help them.And helping is caring.Moreover, if I have millions of dollar, I will give part of my money to charity because they can use the money to cure many people. Also, I will give my money to orphanage because nobody can take care of them as they're at age of 18. So, they can use these money to achieve their goals for future.Last but not least,I will give another half money to my parent.
ReplyDeleteYes, i agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others because after they die they have noting to do with the money but if they help poor they did something good with their money and they save someone life instead of waste it. If you had millions of dollars, i will help myself first if I have money left then I will give it to poor. I feel i should help others less fortunate than i if i have everything I need.
ReplyDeleteI agreed with Andrew Carnegie because it was kind that you help the poor people and maybe some day they will pay you back . If I have million dallars i will not help the poor people because i will save the money to the bank .
ReplyDeleteXD
i disagree with you bacause nobody making you to help the poor peolple even tho you have 1 million dollars
DeleteAkmal 813
AHHHHHHHHH , SO WHAT , THIS IS NONE YOUR BUSINESS.
DeleteI agree with u because rich people can help poor people by sumiyamayna 813
DeleteAkmal813. i agree with carnegie because, you don't have to have a lot of money every time, because if you have a lot of money than you going to die what is going to happen to your money, plus money does't bring happiness
ReplyDeleteI agree with Andrew Carnegie because rich people need to help poor people the poor people have no knowledge then the rich people can use their money to help them and buy some foods. Chenxushi 813
ReplyDeleteI think rich people should help the poor people(people that really poor and can't work,but not always because as you help them more and more, some people think it is naturally for you to help them and not relied/working on themselves.If I have million of dollars, I will donate some money to Orphanage and some poor places.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with Andrew Carnegie because if you have a lot of money you should spend on charity instead of buying useless stuffs.If I have a lot of money I will spend on charity
ReplyDeletei mean by i agree
DeleteI disagree with u because If someone have lot's of money u can help other. BY: Sumiya , Mayna 813
DeleteAbubakr Kahorov 813
ReplyDeleteI agree with Andrew Carnegie because if we have that much money we can help other people not just wasted all of it for ourselves or we can just spend on something else . If we help others they might help us in the future when we have difficult situation
I agree because people who have money should be helping people.
Deletei disagree because ,the money i have is the money i earn from hard work.if i give it to to other then i will need to give away my hard work money
ReplyDeleteI dont agree with you,because if you give out your money that means you are caring other.
Deletei disagree with you because you will not get help when you were poor.and you are not considerate.by :jia wei liu
Delete32ge zan
DeleteI understand what you're trying to say by feeling like you're giving away your money that you worked so hard for but if you don't give at least some of your money, people will think of you as greedy and well, no one really wants to be called that. (Atifah Osrat)
Deletei agree with Andrew Carnegie because if you have lots of money you should at lest use some or give it to your family also you can give to poor to live on
ReplyDeleteby: guadalupe
I agree with Carnegie because it is right and just to give to the less fortunate and I would give all my money to good causes before I died.
ReplyDeleteI agree with caegie that rich people have an obligation to help poor people . Because those money can save lot's of lives . If I had millions of dollars , than I would share it with my friends and family . And donate those money to people who needed it . by Sumiya , Mayna 813
ReplyDeletei agree with what camegie say because if someday you're having a disability of doing something, you would want someone to help you. right? well if i was rich enough and able to help others. Honestly i would help the people that needs my help. sharing something to others is a way of caring. For example, donating money to the charity, help the school with extra supplies and etc....
ReplyDeleteI agree with Andrew and Akmal because why not to help those poor people who do not bed for sleep,food too eat,so i would prefer to help them if i have lots of money.Helping poor people is is good work.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Mr. Fazlay because rich people need to help poor people. by furqan ali
Deleteby;furqan ali
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie because if someone is poor so we should help them. because they are human like us. Pretend if you are poor and you don't have money to feed your kids and your self then how would you stay alive. If i have 1 million dollars first of all, i will give half of them to poor people and buy a house from half of it. People shouldn't waste there money. Instead of wasting there money they could give to poor people.
I agree with ali because that they have to much money which they can use for other people or give to poor people
DeleteI agree with Andrew Carnegie because that we can help poor people to live on because that they are not smart.If I have a million dollars then I will give some to my family,then sane some for myself and use the left over for the poor people that have no house to live in.
ReplyDeleteBy:jason lin
(Habiba 813) i agree with Carnegie because if you are rich instead of hogging all your money you should share with people. If i had millions of dollars i would donate my money to charity. I would share it with people who are less fortunate then me. This is because if i would put myself in their shoes i would want someone to help me.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Carnegie because during this time period lots of people were in property.If you don't help the needy then you will sound really acquisitive because you would rater keep the money to your self when you cant use it then give it to people in need. If i had a million dollars i would give most of it to the needy and the rest to my family.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you when you say that during this time, many people were in need of money which is true because when a person is rich, they shouldn't be greedy. (Atifah Osrat)
Delete(Atifah Osrat)- I agree with Carnegie because during this period of time, a lot of families were in need of money. And, if one is rich, they shouldn't be selfish and greedy. They shouldn't keep the money to themselves. The person should distribute his or her money to the people in need because even if it's a little money, the family would be very grateful. If I ever had a million dollars, I would DEFINITELY share it and give donations to important fundraisers that have a good purpose. For example, cancer research, animals, or families in need from all over the world.
ReplyDeletei agree with u because back then it wasnt easy to make money. in todays world politics and goverment r just corrupt.
Deletei think rich people do have an abligation to care for the poor because in todays day the rich dont pay as much taxes as the other classes and they dont even donate money for a resaerch project or to help find a way to cure diseses. they also dont work as hard as other people
ReplyDeletei agree with you because society should be equalled out with all people.
Deletei agree - Feezan
Deletei agree with andrew carnegie and i think rich do have a responsibility to help the less fortunate than themselves. It is not fair to the people who are poor they have nothing but the rich have more than they can spend. rich should give to keep people more equal to each other, the rich should give 25% the least of there own money to keep carnegies beliefs
ReplyDeletei agree with brendan . - Feezan
Deletethanks for that whatevre it was
Deletei agree with u to because ceos of big companies make around 12 mil today while workers make like 100k
DeleteI agree with Andrew because I would want to help the people with less money
ReplyDeleteI disagree with carnegie because rich people can spend there money how they like.If i had a million dollars i would buy EVERTHING. I feel like i would help the less fortune (poor) by buying them a house and food .Feezan 811
ReplyDeletei agree with you too feezan
Deleteif i had millions i would make sure my family has more then enough to survive and i would maybe donate money to people who r less fortunate.
ReplyDeleteI like what you said because it sounds a lot more reasonable.
Deletei agree with Carnegie and other two posts because if we were wealthy, we should give poor people money. if i was rich, i would donate most of my money to poor people because these people dont have clean clothes, food, clean water and a habitat. if i was in their situation, i would be so sad.
ReplyDeletefrom mena sabeha 811
(Jamima Priti) I agree with Carnegie that the rich have an obligation to help others because there are many poeple and kids suffering from hunger and other things. Therefore, people should do exploits. For example, they should give some of their money to people who really need the money.
ReplyDeletePeople should put themselves in this placement and would you help your own family if they were poor
ReplyDeleteI disagree that they have to share their riches because they work hard for it and if they truly deserve it they shall have it. if i had a million dollars i would donate half of it to people who really need it. If they were people that need desperate help i would donate money -XavierHernandez811
ReplyDeleteI disagree with you because I know what you're trying to say by feeling like you're giving away all the money that you worked hard for but, if you don't give away at least some of your money to good purposes, everyone would consider you as a greedy person which isn't really a good name to be known by (Atifah Osrat)
DeleteI agree with Carnegie because many people in this world such as the poor need money because some are broke.If I had one million dollars i would give some of the money to charity and the poor that i may see on the street also i would use the rest for myself.I also think it is not fortunate to share money with the poor because they are the part of our world and to have a world we need to have humans.
ReplyDelete(Raven Parker 811) I agree with Carnegie because it's not only a generous thing to do, but it's also giving the poor a chance to live. Without money, you can't purchase food, a home, or anything you may need. If I had a million dollars, I'd give at least three quarters of it away to the poor, possibly even more than that. If I have a chance to live, so should everyone else.
ReplyDeleteI really like the way you worded your opinion because it is true. Giving even a little money to the people that need it might even save their lives. (Atifah Osrat)
Deletei agree with carnegie because people should donate money. if i had that much money i would donate half my money to charity and keep the rest. i would donate because i cant do anything with it. also i will have alot of enemies. when people die they don't take their money with them.
ReplyDeletei agree with xavierhernandez811. if i had a million dollars id waist them all on burgers and give the rest to the needy
ReplyDelete(maham rasheda)- I agree with Carnegie that the rich should help others. Theyshould help those in need. Instead of being selish, and arrogant. If we have enough money to feed ourselves and 50 other people than we have enough to help those who suffer. Being rich is one thing knowing you could wake up in the morning not having to worry about hunger, or trying to feed your family, or trying to look for a job. However, there are people out there like that who suffer from hunger, who tries to afford clothes. If we cannot help those in need then who are we?
ReplyDeleteI agree on how you said that if you have enough money to feed yourself and 50 other people then you would have enough money to feed those who are suffering. (Jamima Priti)
DeleteI agree with Andrew Carnegie. If I had a million dollars i would donate of that money to different types of charites. I would help the less fortunate even if I didn't have a million dollars.
ReplyDelete#Help Poor People
I agree U did a good job
DeleteP.S. Mr.jorgenson Hint:Mohammed Amin should get an extra ten points
Jason Garcia-811. I actually disagree with Carnegie, because i do not feel that i should help the poor with my own money that i worked for. I don't think that it is my responsibility to give the poor my own money. If i had a million dollars i would use it for my own joy, or give it to people who need it. Possibly, i would feel that i should help others less fortunate because of how they live.
ReplyDeletehi xavier do u have anything else to add
ReplyDeleterich people should a least share their money with people who need money to live a normal life without hunger, sadness and etc.
ReplyDeletefrom mena sabeha 811
i think rich people should help the poor. Today people that are rich don't help the poor. They should donate to the poor.
ReplyDeleteIf I have million dollar I would give to my family and donate to the people that need help