- Is child labor appropriate in some situations?
- What elements of childhood are we attempting to protect when we regulate child labor? How do the rights of a child differ from general human rights?
Tuesday, January 31, 2017
Child Labor
Child Labor has been used for many centuries throughout the world and was used for over 150 years in the United States. It was initially used to aid the family in farm work and then in factories to speed up production and as a way for factory owners to save money, however,there are a great many people that feel child labor is wrong to use in any instance.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think child labor is appropriate in some situations because they can help there families by providing them with money.They can use the money to by food and clothes for thier families.
ReplyDeleteThey are trying to protect their children from early death.I think children differ because there to young to work. Ian Jaramilo 811
its ok
Delete1 Yeah i agree that sometimes child labor are appropriate in some situation so they can help with the money and their parents dont need to afford as much.
Delete2 I kind of agree and kind of not.
Wendy yang 811
its alright
Deletecristhian zambrano
I agree that child labor is appropriate in some ways they help their parents out working
DeleteNabeel Mohammad 811
I like what you said for your first qustion about using money to buy clothes and food for your family. But i think you should more details on your second one like what some right we have that child back then did t
Delete-MujiburShaad811
I agree with the first one they are try to help their to help their family's. for the second one it is more then one reason like they also needed a education
DeleteJAVIER DIAZ
Child labor is deplorable. Children can spend their childhood to get an education. However, they are being forced to work. Also, the children were being treated unfairly with little wage and very bad working conditions. Mohammad Ijaz 822
Deletehelp their help their nice grammar
Deleteto: Javiett
Michelle 822
Guys please help mujibar with his grammar and may jesus help javier with his grammar of an elephant
DeleteFROM: Rafiul Ur FRiend
TO: MUJI AND JAVIII
The business owners weren't very smrt
DeleteChild labor would only be appropriate if it was safe and better paying.
Delete^Mohammad Ijaz 822
DeleteSome Child labor are appropriate to some situations cause they family might need to get money to help keep them alive or to help someone get medicine to help someone get cure.Child labor is completely different from the rights we have now be cause back then people probably thought children couldn't do as much as adults which means they shouldn't have the same rights as them.
ReplyDeleteRonald He 811
i agree with you ronald because in most situations it is appropriate for child labor but not to much use
DeleteI agree with you when say they had to work to get medicine and get someone a cure because in some cases that is the situation. Why didn't I think of that.
Delete-Sabina 811
how do you decide what is too much?
Delete1)The child labor appropriate in some situation is that children and kids are working in the factories for a long time in a very low age. Children went to work when they are very young. So I think child labor is not appropriate in the situation. Also it might because that children should go to school in the young age to get educated and find a better job when they grow up.
ReplyDelete2)The difference between the kids from now to then is that early pass, kids need to work in the factories in age about 8-10. Now children can't work or find a job in the very young age, it will be against the laws. We have many free times to play with instead of working in the factories. In addition, kids will not have time to eat working in the factories but we have many things to eat. In the pass, some factory workers will tie the child to the factory machine because they are worried the child will run away.
Wen Jian Lin Class: 811
i agree with you because i think that in some cases child labor is appropriate to work in factories since you could pay them less. Also i agree with your answer for #2 cause we could now get to go to school and have fun with our friends unlike them back then.-kathyfung 811
Deletei think u have a good point about how the kids are tie to the machine so they do not run away.
DeleteWendy yang811
1. In some rare situations child labor is appropriate when the children have to help their parents earn a good living because the parents don't earn enough. However child labor is a horrible thing. Sometimes children die because of the machines. children at the ages of 5 are hired to help run the machines. Their childhood was taken away from them.
ReplyDelete2. Our life from when we were young differs from the kids life back then because we have rights. The children back then had a sad life, they never got to play. When I was younger I had a good childhood. I was never forced to work at such a young age, I went to school and had an education. The little kids back then all they did was work. They never got to play and be a normal kid. They never got a chance to have an education. All they did was work to help their families.
-Sabina 811
i agree with you totally cause child labor isn't a good thing waking up before the sunrise and working til sun set.Also not having a education being this young and starting to work
DeleteROna\Ald 811
I totally agree with you.
Delete-Sabina 811
1- I believe that in some situations child labor is not appropriate. Its not appropriate at all because they are still children and they should be in school and not working in factories where they can get hurt or killed.
ReplyDelete2-Our rights as kids are different from those child workers back then because now have to go to school and not be working.However back then those who can pay for school fee can go to school and those who cant have to go work or take care of there families.Also the rights of a child is different from general human rights because the adults got paid more and the children got paid less plus they had to do very dangerous jobs unlike the adults.-kathy fung 811
1. I agree with you Kathy because its sad when you think about the fact that children are killed by these horrible machines
Delete2. I also agree with you because I feel that the children should be paid more than adults because children could die because of those machines. The adults most of the time had safe jobs.
-Sabina 811
i disagree with ur point at the first question. It is because sometimes kids can help their parents do chorces and go outside and do safe jobs and earn money.
Delete2. i agree with in ur second point because it is dangerous for kids to work in the machines. They can also get hurt often too.
Wendy yang 811
1. I think that child labor are appropriate get paid fairly. But only in some cases. It is only when there are small chores and works that only kids could do. But i dont agree that kids need to work like adults. And they are not suppose to do danger jobs too
ReplyDelete2. Our rights as kids now are different than it use to be. We are different now because now we go to school and when we come home we eat, sleep and play video games. But back then they had to work,work and work. the rights that child have are different then general human rights because the owner paid adults more than child. While child had more hard and more danger work. \
Wendy Yang 811
I agree with u because i also believe that kids should not be working like adults and not be doing dangerous jobs like the adults do. Also our rights now is that we have to go t school unlike them back then. plus now we could just go home and rest unlike them were they have to work for 13-16 hours a day.-kathyfung 811
Deletei agree with you because the kids are always paid less.
DeleteAnnie Chen 811
agree with you on question number 1 by saying they are not suppose to do danger jobs and by comparing to the adults. I want to add to what you said by saying that kids doesn't go to school to get educated but going to work in the factories.
DeleteWen Jian Lin Class:811
1. I agree with you when you say kids don't need to work like adults. Even if they did work all they could be doing could be like cleaning and doing chores.
Delete2. children back then had a hard life then we do now. Children back then had to earn something by working for it .
-Sabina 811
child labor was not appropriate in some situations because the kids could have a high chance of injury while working in a factory
ReplyDeletewere trying to save the kids from the danger from being injured or being killed.When there small they are asked to put there hand in the machine to see whats wrong with it and that increases the chance at death
cristhian zambrano 811
your response was informational and good
DeleteIan jaramillo 811
Having children being injured is not appropriate in anyway i agree with u that kids have a high chace of dying in a factory because they might have small hands to fix something but thier not skilled or know how to do it which rasies their chaces of losing a limb.
DeleteROnalf 811
i agree that child labor can kill the child and a high chance of injury. Andy Chen 811
Delete1)I THINK THAT child labor was wrong but in some situations its needed to stop the machine but the kids can get caught inside of the machine and die at a young age
ReplyDelete2)to make them go to school to help their families.The rights of chidren should have the freedom of speech to say what they need to do to help themselves and their families.Nicolas vona class 811
I agree that the child should have freedom of speech and say what they want.Andy Chen 811
Delete1) Child labor is only appropriate in some situations because it not good for kids. some families were poor, or they need to pay for the medical fees. in these situations, child labor is appropriate.
ReplyDelete2) the elements that we are attempting to protect when we regulate child labor is not to tie them with a rope with the machine. this is because tying them with a rope will make them hurt by the machines by accidents. The rights of a child differ from general human rights because today, kids always go to school and go home. But then back then, the kids always go to work and not get educated.
Annie Chen 811
ReplyDelete1.child labor are not appropriate in some situation because when they work in factories they will get hurt.
ReplyDelete2.the element of childhood are we attempting to protect when we regulate child labor was to let them have time to go to school. and build a free school for poor family child can go to. also, the owner should short the hour of the working time,because they have long hour of working time that made them be very tired. the right of a child differ from general human right was children have to right to work less hour than the adult. -mq 811
mengqing--811
Deletehow can it not be appropriate in other ways?
DeleteAnnie Chen 811
it can not be appropriate when they work long hour of time and make them looks older,and look tired.also it not appropriate because children work in long hours of time in factories,but they get very less amount of money.--mengqing
Delete1)I think child labor not appropriate in some situations because some of the child can get kill but they can help if the thing they are doing is not dangers
ReplyDelete2)They are trying to protect the child from growing up too fast and so that not as many child will not get kill and so that they can go to school.The right of a child differ from general human right because child have to go to school to learn. Andy Chen 811
I agree with you in number one but child labor was also appropriate because they earned money to help their family to survive.
Delete- Fahima 811
1) Yes child labor is appropriate in some situation like if your family is deapert and they needs the money you could put your child to work and the could make some money. If better starving to death
ReplyDelete2) I think every child should have the right to learn and go to school like a regular child. They should have fun and play outside not work at a factory for about a 16 hours a day they are not machine they are human like everyone else. Also a child should make relationship and make friend with each and other not work.
-MujiburShaad 811
I agree with you Mujibur, I believe every children should have the right to go to school to learn and to have fun. After when they turn into adult, they had to work. Therefor, their childhood is their only time in life to enjoy their life.
Delete*Wei Zhuang 811*
1) Child labor is not appropriate in any situation because due to the fact that many children have been injured and killed by doing dangerous jobs. And it stole the childhood of many children.
ReplyDelete2) The rights of a child differ from general human right because the general human rights are to go to school, time to play, time to read and write. But, the children had no time to go to school or time to play, and most of all sometimes they lost their own life because they were always working.
-Fahima Akter 811
How did it stool children childhood u should add more deltail mujiburshaad811
DeleteI think child labor is not appropriate because it has been used for many centuries and under go for 150 year in united states.
ReplyDeleteThe elements of a childhoofd is to get a education go to school everyday have fun Nabeel Mohammad 811
1) In some situations I believe that child labor is appropriate because child labor was suppose to help the country. It was used to increase and help our economy become better and more powerful. although people may not treat it like that but in this situation i think that child labor was appropriate in some circumstances like helping our economy.
ReplyDelete2) The rights of the child workers are different from ours now because instead of going to work we go to school to get educated. Due to working, they are unable to connect with their family or spend much time with them. Many kids weren't able to make much friends and develop a positive outgoing mind set. They were often depressed and unhappy. Now kids are more successful and happy with the things they do.
1)i think child labor can be appropriate in some situations but I also thick a child shouldn't work at a young age. the youngest age a child should work is 12. I don't think a child should work at a factory even if there are younger then 17.
ReplyDelete2)elements of children labor i would try to protect is letting the children go to school and enjoy them self. it wouldn't be 13 to 1 hours of work.
JAVIER DIAZ
i agree with your response but i think you should add more to your first and second answer.-kathyfung811
DeleteI agree with you on question number 1 by saying they are not suppose to do danger jobs and by comparing to the adults. I want to add to what you said by saying that kids doesn't go to school to get educated but going to work in the factories.
ReplyDeleteWen Jian Lin Class:811
1) Child labor is only appropriate when the child is doing small chores to help the family. In some situations, however, it is inappropriate. For example, sending the kid to work for a long period of time for a low salary.
ReplyDelete2) Children from this generation have different rights as well as life style than children during the period of child labor. Children had to work for somewhere from 8-14 hours a day. Children had no time to enjoy their childhood, due to the situation of their family. They have less time to spend with their family since they are constantly working. They can't go to school to get a education, therefor a child who worked in a factory are probably going to work there for their whole life.
---Wei Zhuang 811---
1) In some situations I believe that child labor is appropriate because child labor was suppose to help the country. It was used to increase and help our economy become better and more powerful. although people may not treat it like that but in this situation i think that child labor was appropriate in some circumstances like helping our economy.
ReplyDelete2) The rights of the child workers are different from ours now because instead of going to work we go to school to get educated. Due to working, they are unable to connect with their family or spend much time with them. Many kids weren't able to make much friends and develop a positive outgoing mind set. They were often depressed and unhappy. Now kids are more successful and happy with the things they do.
xiao ting li 811
i agree with your answers because child labor did help our countries in a very huge way. Also your right cause our rights now are that we have to get an education but those children didn't.-kathy fung 811
DeleteI think that child labor was appropriate to one condition only, that condition would be to help provide for their families.I feel that no child should undergo working in such horrible conditions at such young ages. The elements of childhood that we should protect when we regulate child labor would b the right to have an education. These kids are working in the factories at such young ages which restricts them from being raised properly into a normal life. If they are working in the factories for such long hours they can't be raised by their parents the proper way. They can't learn right from wrong by their parents. These kids have a right to an education for their future careers. Children's rights are different from general human rights because these kids had to work in hazardous conditions instead of being in a school and learning from a teacher. This is what I think should be protected from regulating child labor. - Sabrina Basant 811
ReplyDeleteI believe child labor is not appropriate in any situation because it puts them in danger and they can get sick or weak because of the lack of sunlight and exercise. In some factories the machines would let out smoke and pollute the air which can damage the child's lungs. It is unfair for children to work in dangerous factories for so many hours and get paid so little. -Melanie.C. 811
ReplyDeleteI agree because the kids were put to harm and were able to get sick or worse die. Anthony Zhou 822
Delete1. i think child libor is inappropraite because they are too young to do those works and in some situation they will be sick,they had no time to play,and to be educated.child labor start in that time are just horrible and terrible that cause many child in that young age died cause of long hours working and less relaxing time that dust air may cause them bad health.
ReplyDelete2. child may get health problems, hurt on legs, with less relaxing time cause them sleepy and dead into the machine as he/she cant controlled it or have no power to do works because of tiredness.I think to protect children is not make them to do too much works in a factories but may get in easier jobs for them to do. But the most important is they need to get educated for reading, writing and time to play and make more friend to communicate. Today, laws that are now protected child is not to have jobs if he/she are not adults like 18 years old or over. Every child is being educated, and have time to play... nina 811
1)It is never appropriate to use kids for child labor kids should be worry free.They should be out playing with there friends. They should not be worried whether or not they did there work right. Some kids worry about the money they have to bring home.In some families the kids are the ones that bring the money home.some times the parents don't work. sherlyn ramirez
ReplyDelete1.Hell no, In what ret***** case is it good!?!!? Child labor cant be good cause no child is gonna want to work for 12 hours straight something like if we from montuak got 12 hours of school(if it was legal) no body wants that people want rest, the company managers are the only ones who benefit from child labor.
ReplyDelete2.if we are gonna protect any element of childhood its gotta be the fun parts even though during those times there really wasnt fun times. but probably during that time people would wanna protect the cycle of growing up.Child rights differ cause kids arent fully grown so they are belittled in 2017 for example once your 18 you get to drive by yourself with out assistance but no one bothers to find out if a 15 year old can drive.
NAZMUL PRANTA 802
I Agree with your your point about child labor that they shouldn't be working.
DeleteWeiChen 802
I disagree with your first answer because if they are living in poverty and their parents cant support the family the child is not supposed to just starve and be lucky to find a meal, they are supposed to try to get a meal for the ENTIRE family.-Jamal 802
Deletedont lie to your self you know that im right first i said imagine!!!!!! also its a relation so are u telling me you want to work/ stay in school for 12 hours!!!!!?!
DeleteNazmul 802
1.I think that it is appropriate, because they need the money to raise their family. They have to buy supplies for their family like clothing and food.If they don't go to work they will be starving to death.
ReplyDelete2.The elements of children labor i would try to protect is letting the kids do what they wanted to do, and goes to school to learn and be a successful person. -Caojiewu 802
I agree with you on #1 because children can work if they must support their family.
DeleteZhiWeiZhang 802
I agree with you about gaining money for their family but it wasn't the right way to do it. Those kids didn't have to go through that just fora bit of money
DeleteMarcos Saucedo 802
1)For some reasons i think child labor is never appropriate.They were using young kids to do those dangerous job and bring money home.young kids should be playing outside but not working in a factories.
ReplyDelete2)Our rights as kids were different from child labor in some ways.Children in child labor were working on the factories and they were not playing with other kids outside.Kids in child labor were doing dangerous job in the factories and support their family with the money they earn.Now we go to school but kids in child labor weren't.
Weichen 802
I agree it was never appropriate to use kids to work in factories. Kids at those years should of been playing outside or instead going to school. Marcos 802
Delete1) I think child labor is appropriate in some situations because they can get income if their parents have a bad job or don't work at all. This helps their family because if they live in poverty they need a meal and this could help them.
ReplyDelete2)When you regulate child labor you attempting to give the child a good education. If child labor was not prevented then children won't be as smart as they are today. They would be mentally and physically exhausted. The rights of a child differ from the rights of a general human because there are laws that prevent the child from working late and the child has to have a good working environment.
-Jamal 802
Delete1. It is appropriate sometime because there are family are very poor and need money, in this case child have to work to support their family.
ReplyDelete2. The right of children in this timeline is very different than the children that lives during modern time.They can go to school because they were poor, and they have to work so there is no time for they to play or relax.
-Eric wu 802
DeleteI agree with you that it is appropriate sometime because they can help out their families by proving money for them to buy foods and clothing's.
Delete-AndyLi 802
i agree with you because some times that kids must work to support their family in order to survive.
Deleteweichen 802
1. There are some situation child labor is appropriate. For example when child is an orphan with nobody that could support. The orphan can go to work to get some income for surviving.
ReplyDelete2. People protect children for going to work is because children can go to school. If children can go to school they would have knowledge and maybe made the world better. Also child right are different from general human right because child right are for the child which is not even a adult yet. General human right are more forward to adult.
ZhiWeiZhang 802
I agree with the point that child labor is appropriate in some situation, and grammar mistake
Delete-Eric wu 802
1)Child labor is appropriate in some situations because they can help out their family by providing moneys for buying foods and clothing's.
ReplyDelete2) Back then kids have to work for a long period of time instead of going to school. Now days kids gets to go to school not going on a field and work for almost the whole day.
-AndyLi 802
It is true about your point that the money they make is used to buy food and clothes but need detail.
Delete-Eric wu 802
i disagree with ur statment for 1 children are forced to do it along with the parents the parents want there children to work cause of the lack of money but if there wasnt a lack of money u gotta think that the child would be having school.
DeleteNazmul Pranta 802
I agree with you because children can work for helping the family.
DeleteZhiWeiZhang 802
1.I think child labor is not appropriate because child in such a young age shouldn't be working in a factory.that they should be in having education and having fun.Also because that working in a factory is dangerous and the child and get hurt and even die.
ReplyDelete2.They are trying to protect the child from growing up too fast and so that not as many child will get kill and that they can go to school.The right of a child different from general human right because child have to go to school to learn and do other things.
-shi, chen xi
some situation does`t allow child to go to school and have fun they must work to support their family. -Eric wu 802
DeleteI disagree with your first answer because if the family is living in poverty and the parents can't support the family the child is not supposed to stand around and starve, they are supposed get their family a meal.
Delete-Jamal 802
Delete1) it is not appropriate to use kids for child labor.Kids can help by supporting their family by working but they were paid to less.
ReplyDelete2)they have to work 10-12 hours instead of going to school to learn.now everyone gets to get education. children's life in the past is sad
Xing Huang Qiu 802
But it better than getting nothing to support their families.
Delete-AndyLi 802
Deletei agree with you xing huang
-802
Need to write more. Explain #1 more -Caojiewu 802
DeleteCao Jie is correct... you do need to explain more about why you agree with the post, however, Cao Jie do you agree or disagree with this post?
Delete1.I think child labor was appropriate in some situations because in young age children can get experience and know what to do for a job.And they can earn money for their family.
ReplyDelete2.The different is we can get education and we didn't need to work in factories for long hours doing dangerous machines. KellyXiao-802
I agree with you that child labor is only appropriate when helping their family earn money.-Linda Li 802
Delete1. Child Labor is not appropriate in situations because it makes children young and in their teenage years working in factories and the children sometimes get injured or killed. 2.children are not ready to work their entire lives. They need t go to school to learn and also play game and hangout it their friends. Christopher Mills 802
ReplyDeletei disagree with your 1st point as children had no choice but to work in the industrial period because of the the extreme poverty-Alvin Gaine 802
Delete1) I believe that child labor is never appropriate in any situations. I believe that because in any type of situation, good or bad, its still going to be bad because child labor is kids working really hard instead of having fun and enjoying their childhood. Also many kids could get injured or even die due to child labor.
ReplyDelete2) The elements of childhoods that we should protect when we regulate child labor would have to be the right of having an education.Kids are working instead of learning instead of working they should be in school learning. They don't have time to learn from their teachers or parents, to teach them whats right or wrong. Children should have the right to have an eduction and to have time to make friends and have fun.
--Nathaly Salas 802
1. No child labor is not appropriate depending the situation because children cant enjoy there childhood because of child labor. Child labor harms them physically and emotionally.
ReplyDelete2. Trying to protect the childs health is one of the elements. The right of a child and adults are different because a child still has a lot of growth to do and living. But child labor causes many children to not be able to have the chances to observe a full life. For example, a child get hurts while working all because of a machine. Or a child may have died because he or she may have slipped of a machine or got caught by a machine.
Jakelln 802
I belive that a part of child labor was appropiate because it helped their familys earn and save money. the neggative affect to this was that chiLdren Didint get to enjoy their child hood and go to school and learn how to speak, read, and write.After all it was terrible and affected kids allot.
ReplyDeleteThe elements that we are attempting to protect when we regulate child labor is that we are not trying to make them work for little or no money, it is for their safety and freedom.the diffrence beetween now and then is that kids could work at a young age but now, a kid at the age of 8 cant work in a factory or farm because its illigal.Also its for the safety of the kids these days because if they work they could end up injured and could eventually die because their body cant handle the hard work (they're not used to it).
Richard Juarez 802
1. Child labor was only appropriate for one reason which is the kids were getting money for their families which was helping out the family in a big way.
ReplyDelete2) I think they are trying to protect kids from early death.The children's most likely to get hurt and sick from working all day long. This might cause them to get tired and sleepy and that can lead them to not pay attention to what the machine is doing and that can lead to child death. Also, child labor is isolating kids from going to school and having an education. But in the 21st century there are kinds that's going to school and
having an education and working as they desire when they are 18 or older.
-Somaia Sarker
802
i disagree with you on your 2nd point as in my opinion people wanted more to develop the growth and learning and perfect the tools they need to perfect in life-Alvin Gaine 802
Deleteduring the industrial revolution, many families lived with extreme poverty and required every member of the family to work somewhere and earn money, children needed to work to stay alive and survive and to keep their families from poverty. the children had no choice during this period of modernization but to work in factories and earn money, this was an appropriate time for them to work as they had to carry their own and their families burden. when we protect children we focus heavily on their learning and growth and not their playtime or imagination because people acquire the tools to carry out the rest of their lives. the rights of a child differ from general rights because children are yet to develop the sense that tells them right from wrong, the common sense that all adults hold they do not have-Alvin Gaine 802
ReplyDelete1) I believed there's never a appropriate situation for a kid in their tender age to work in such a dangerous working condition. Kids under 16 should attend in school and having educations, instead of working in under dangerous environment of long hours during a day.
ReplyDelete2) The elements of childhood we are attempting to protect when we regulate child labor is decreased the working hours to 4-5 hours for children in the factories and increased the minimum working age to 14, same as the modern day. As a result children could have time to play and get education.--Jinlingzheng802
I agree with your answer that children shouldn't work long hour in factories.-Linda Li 802
DeleteI agree with you that children should have time to play and get education because if they keep working all the day they may just be boring. And they can go to school to get knowledge. KellyXiao-802
Delete1) child labor isn't appropriate in any situation!!! Child labor was negligent in america. These children were at risk with any job they had to do, it was really dangerous for them. They didnt even get education because they needed money for themselves and their family. Several kids didnt even get payed it was all unfair. No child should have to go through what most of these kids went through.
ReplyDelete2) today most kids dont work , instead they go to school to get education and if they do work they work for a certain amount of time and they get paid a certain amount of money. Long ago the jobs were all dangerous and more risky ~ Reynaa 802
1)In certain aspects, child labor may be acceptable depending on the situation. During the time, some families struggled with extreme poverty, and as all family members to work in order to at last put food on the table. If children weren’t working they would be living in even greater poverty.If families are living in poverty they may rely heavily on their child’s income to provide food, shelter for them. It is suggested that they would have
ReplyDelete2) Childhood is a fundamental stage in our life time, where we learn to interact, play, and most importantly get an education. Working in factories limits or gives no time for children to have any fun or do something that will be beneficial. As children we use creative thinking a lot more than we do as adults. Working in the same hazardous conditions could be crucial to a child's life and psychology. This forces them to grow up a lot quicker and be responsible for every little aspect. These are basic human rights that need to be preserved and taken advantage of. -Faress B. 802
1) There is nothing appropriate about using kids to work in factories and working in bad conditions. Kid are have to be able to have fun at their age and start learning so they could be ready to face obstacles when they are older.Kids shouldn't be working at this age.
ReplyDelete2) We are trying to protect the well being of the children.Protecting them from all the bad thing that could effect them in a awful way.For children to work it really ain't helping the children to say safe and healthy. The rights of the children differs from from a general human because they are kids. They are not at the right age to protest or sue somebody. Child labor was an event that many children will remember.
Marcos Saucedo 802
1.In my perspective child labor is appropriate only in one condition, is helping their families earn money. But they are too young to work in factory which has no fresh air and was often dirty. Some children died because of working long hours in factories.
ReplyDelete2.The elements of childhood we attempted to protect when we regulate child labor is let children go to school not work in factories. Children supposed to get education and make friend.
Linda Li 802
1) Child labor appropriate in certain situation like helping there family with money for living. Some family are poor and cant afford things for living, in this situation child labor is appropriate because its better than starving.
ReplyDelete2)Kids right today are very different from rights back then because back then kids work in factories at a young age and they didn't get any education or fun. Now kids go to school and doesn't have to work until they are older. -Vicky Wang 802
i agree with you by saying that child labor is good by can help the family get money because a lot of family is poor and don't have alot of good things
Deletejanezheng 821
1.child labor are not appropriate in any kind of situations.because children that are working in the factories are orphans that get treated poorly because no one would care if they get hurt.
ReplyDelete2.our life now differ from the children in the past because ow we are so lazy but back then kids our age had to work and didn't have the chance to go to school.-linlinlu802
1.I think child labor is not appropriate in some situation because children are too young to work in factories and they can get hurt or injured from doing dangerous tasks that is not for their age.The factories condition is terrible for children because there is no fresh air and dust is everywhere in the factories.It can affect children health and cause them to have short term life.
ReplyDelete2.The elments that we attempt to protect are not let children to go school to be edcated. The rights of a child are different from human right by child can not go school to be educated and they only work in factoies.I think children should go to school to learn how to read and write.jialinwu802
1) child labor is bad in several ways because children at such a young age shouldn't be working especially in bad conditions yes, children are smaller and can get hurt easily they can slip and fall and fracture something. They can work but not to young.But however there's also a good part because that means they would help out their parents with anything that is needed in the household but bad also because they didn't get the chance to go to school and learn like any other kid of that age.
ReplyDelete2) the rights of child labor are different today because child labor isn't allowed in some states child labor does exist in some states but instead of working now children attend school.children go to school and in the afternoon do their homework and enjoy the time they have left over back then they couldn't because they had to work and couldn't do anything because they had no time they always had to work.
-Vianey Perez 802
1) In some cases child labor was appropriate since children would go work in factories to provide their families with money to buy what they need to keep on going.
ReplyDelete2) The elements that you could try to protect is to possibly limit the hours of work for the children so that could help lower the health risks. I don't think the rights of a child should differ from general human rights, as it would be unfair for the children, since they are taken for granted because of their age,etc.
Delete-Diamon Roebuck 822
i agree with u children would work or be forced to work and help their family
DeleteMichelle 822
1. No, child labor is not appropriate in some situations because they are too young to work in dangerous jobs and they can get killed by doing so.
ReplyDelete2. They are trying to protect kids from being used as much and almost be killed. They are different to human rights because they have a government that protects us and a right o humans with laws. Children had different ones when used as child labor.
Kevin Rozanski 822
HOw are their rights different? Are they?
DeleteKevin,I agree with you about not using child labor in some situations.Like I said, this affect how children see themselves.This will cause them to be TRIGGERED.
Delete(AGamer12) eLi 822
As much as it might trigger the children, child labor did help the businesses and more money was brought in the country because of this. Mohammad Ijaz 822
DeleteIn some cases child labor was appropriate since children would go work in factories to provide for their families
ReplyDeletehow are the rights different from the right a human do? yexi lin 822
Deletei do not think child labor was right for children at small ages.This will cause children to change their way of living.This will start a life of depression and insecurity.This will show how they feel after working long hours.In some situations,i don't even think child labor is right... EVEN FOR PUNISHMENT!This will affect the child physically and mentally.
ReplyDelete-(AGamer12)eLi 822
I agree, because they don't deserve too work in long hours and be sick or ill, even be killed or injured.
DeleteKevin Rozanski 822
I agree because those children might develop son physical and mental and probably emotionally problems when they grow up
DeleteMArio Sotomayor 821
1. Child labor is sometimes appropriate in dire situations, during industrialization where people barely made enough money to survive. However, times when children are not required to work like now, it isn't appropriate to force them to work
ReplyDelete2. When we try and regulate child labor, we are trying to keep children from working too much and to give them an education and more time with their families. We also do this to make sure that children in the future know what to do what to do with their children.
-Darius Wong 822
I agree with your explanation
Deletemegan822
1) I think child labor was not appropriate for kids to work there because those kids are just too young. Some kids were just young that didn't understand what harmful stuff are. Some conditions such as tiredness, injuries are awful cause the people that work there dont care. These children gets affected physically and emotionally. 2)One of the elements is education. some of the children were working so hard that they didnt even have time to to study and learn English. Health was another reason why children didnt have time for. Children are supposed to enjoy their childhood and have fun before they enter adult hood and actually work like them.
ReplyDeletethat is me ----Shakhzoda Nimatulloyeva 822
DeleteWouldn't working build up character in a person regardless of age? That would make it ok wouldn't it?
Deleteya it would, but children are supposed to enjoy their childhood not work. When they grow up then they could. but they need education like us.
DeleteThere are some situations of where child labor is appropriate for example if the family needs money and if only the child agrees than it is okay. Though in general i disagree with child labor and think it should be ban.(2) The element that we are trying to protect from child labor are there safety. A general adult has different rights from children because as an adults they have more rights because of since there older they understand the how the world works and know how to control there self but children don't. Anthony Zhou 822
ReplyDeleteI agree with your first point but I disagree with your second point. I think that some children have more self control than adults and just because they are older doesn't mean that they understand more about the world
Delete1 i think child labor was inappropriate in some ways because many children needs to get educated during the age they have now, also they would get bullied by the rich children that knows a lots of knowledge.
ReplyDelete2 the elements of childhood we are attempting to protect when we regulate child labor were,children were working instead of going to school and getting educated.the rights of a child differ from general human rights was that they don't have the to go to school and they also don't have their own time of playing all their life was just working at the factories.
yexi lin 822
Megan Lian 822
ReplyDelete1.No, its not appropriate to let children work in factory because in this age kids were suppose to go to school and learn things instead of working in factory with bad condition. These work are for adults.
2.Our life were different from the children before because now we had right and freedom. In the past child between 7-10 years old need to work in the factory to support their family. Therefore, when they were adult they will had a hard time find job because they didn't go to school.
I agree with you Megan, children were supposed to be in school but instead, they were sent to factories and work to make money. I also agree with what you said for second one, as the work was only for adults and the poor had their children work in factories.
DeleteKevin Rozanski 822
Delete1) i think child labor is not appropriate because child should have the right to go school, although they are poor, children go to school to have knowledge and later on the year, they grow up to help the person who raised them up.
ReplyDelete2) To me, i think they should go to school and have knowledge, but they don't have money, so they were forced to go work for 24hrs , but still they get less money. But some money is better than no money.
Kevin Chen 822
i think child labor is appropriate because sometimes their parents really might really need there help to earn more money. Elements of childhood we are trying to protect is their education, health,and play time. Rights of a child is different from human rights. A child cannot vote, no voice in the government;however, the adults can.
ReplyDeleteJenny Chen 822
How about the ability to develop relationships with people in their age groups and proper adult child relationships? I agree with your points
DeleteI agree,since childhood is to enjoy and learn.
DeleteTingyue 822
1) I think child labor was not appropriate because children must work for a long time and is treated badly.Also, the factory are dangerous.
ReplyDelete2)The elements of childhood are we attempting to protect when we regulate child labor is not letting children go to school.The rights of a child differ general human right when child don't have rights can't vote, and have no voice. Amy chen 822
Amy is that the only thing we are trying to protect when limiting child labor? Is there more?
DeleteBy: Yi Sen Zeng (822)
ReplyDelete1) Child Labor shouldn't be appropriate in some situation, because it will give the children some negative effect. For example, their fingers or their feet will get hurt by the machine. Moreover their communication will get worse since they dont talk to each other.
2) I will make child labor better by giving them more time to take a break like 30 minutes and giving them a right to do things, not just stay there and do work. Last give them some fresh air since the windows are shut. The difference are they have more time , they have a voice and fresh air for their body.
what things can they do to improve their communication skills? yexi lin 822
Delete1.) I agree that child labor is not the best thing. However, child labor is appropriate in some situations. For example, children are able to have some experience. They know how hard it is for their parents to work every day in those terrible factories. When these kids grow up, they will understand how hard life is and will try to improve their life. Also, children will b able to help their parents with money. Even though money is just a dirty piece of paper. It help you to get food, water, clothes, and shelter. All necessary for survival.
ReplyDelete2.) We are trying to safe life not the children own. these little humans that have to grow up an become something important. Children work many hours in factories that cause there deaths. Instead these children need to go to school, get an education and grow up as an educated adult that had many challenges at the beginning. Children and adults have many differences. Children work many hour with these killing machines. They risk their life and earn only cents a day. That is terrible. Adults earn more. Also a child's voice is nothing against an adult. That is so unfair. How can adult be more important than a child. All adults where children before. Adults are more important, educated, and well payed. Unlike children. Children lived in a free country without having freedom.
Kat from 822
Very nicely written Kat and I do agree with you on your points
DeleteIn child labor is appropriate only in one condition, is helping their families earn money. but they are too young to work in factory which has no fresh air and it is often dirty too, which is not good for there healt. many childrens weere sick cause they don't use to get the fresh air, that was affacting there health so badly- Nafisa 822
ReplyDelete1)I don't think that children should be appropriated to work because they were working in these dangerous conditions that they can die in.
ReplyDelete2)they should be protected by putting on some protection because many children died without protection. Some children cut themselves to death or there wasn't fresh air because of the thick dust from the factory windows not being opened
-Michelle 822
1) Child Labor should't be allowed because children have to work in bad conditions and earn a less amount of money. Children can get hurt while working in unsafe conditions and the windows were all closed and they cant breath in oxygen.
ReplyDelete2) I will make child labor better by giving the children more time on breaks like 30 minutes because back then the children get 15 minutes break. They should get some fresh air because they didn't get any fresh air while working so they have to breath in bad air. I will also make child labor better by giving them more money like 3 dollars everyday. -Jimmy Wu 822
1)Child labor is not appropriate in some situations. For example, child labor is bad since kids are in such horrible conditions, they have to breath in gas which is really bad for there lungs. Also, since they are standing on tall objects,and they are in front of big machines, they could fall, or get stuck in the machines. They are also loosing education since they have to work longer hours to support their family. Although, its not all that bad since they are working to raise money.
ReplyDelete2)Were trying to protect children from loosing their education and childhood since they are wasting all their time working and playing or learning. People pay more attention to grown ups rather than kids because they think what kids have to say is not important for some reason. Although if you really think about it,grown ups were once kids too and they also got ignored,so why would nobody care about kids?
-Kubaro 822
so you mean its bad but then good?
Delete1: Its appropriate for child labor to exist for two two reasons. One reason its its a way to support the family get more money in order to support the family. Its also a way that owners that make these kids work they can make kids work and its cheap the owners were making a profit.
ReplyDelete2:One way people can protect child labor is giving them a voice some one to stand up for them no one wants to be forced.This goes to the part that people have the right to stand up and speak for themselves while on the other hand kids were just made to work without no opinions but most importantly a voice for themselves.{^_^}*Miguel capulin 822
1. Sometimes the child labor may be appropriate,since some parents is not even able to support themselves. When the families is so poor that parents cant even get food, in that case when they send their child to work that's reasonable.
ReplyDelete2.When we are regulating child labor, we're trying to protect them with the education they should have.During their childhood, they should enjoy it.Because of parents forcing them to work,they can't learn,they cant have enough time to sleep.In addition ,it health problem may increase as they work each day.Other than what we protect from children,children's right is differ from adults.They're not able to have voice in the government,and they can't vote like adults.When they're child, the're still growing,their opinions about a certain things may changed every time. Each time the adults did something, they need to pay of what they do.However, for child the punishment is going lighter,since many children does not know what are they doing.The children may be same as adult in some point, but they may have different opinion on certain things.
Tingyue dong 822
I agree that children need to go to school and learn and they have to listen to parent.
Delete-Si Ting Chen 821
1. Yes, i think child labor is appropriate in some situations because their parent doesn't earn a lot of money to support their family. So the children need to support their family by going to the factories to work or else they cant survive.
ReplyDelete2. The elements of childhood we attempted to protect when we regulate child labor is to let them go to school instead of working all day in the factories. Working in factories may causes health problems or the child may have injuries. Moreover, in the past children started working from the age of 7-10, so they don't have time to go to school and learn. This can affect their future.
-Jennegca Chen 822
i agree with you but what about children childhood what happens to it when they work in the factory for they entire life pretty much they entire life for little to no pay is it really worth working in the factory
Deleteby Hasan Tasnemul 821
I do think child labor is appropriate when the child itself agree to do it or when they are in desperate need of money. When we use child labor, children lose their childhood which include education and fun. Child don't really know about human rights, meaning they can't use these against people or go to court if they are being mistreated.
ReplyDelete-Alan Lin Class 821
i disagree with you because the children are being force to work in the factories and at the age of now, the children should be at school getting educated.
Deletemichael xiao 821
first off they didn't have education in the past when child labor was present thats why the went to the facory but the other half i agree because there young they don't have an idea of how the world works
DeleteKernan kong 821
I think that sometimes they should go to work to provide extra money for their families but sometimes they need an better education.-Ryan Jiang 821
Delete1)in some situation child labor is appropriate because hey need to earn the money to keep their family up, they need money to buy food. They need to bring the money back to their parent, they can also help wit the business at home.
ReplyDelete2)the element is that to let child work less hour. they also need to upgrade the condition of the place they are working in.it have different rights by adult will thunk that kids can't do anything or do any right thing. so the right of child will be lower then general human because they don't think that child will be right.
jane zheng 821
i disagree with you because the children are being force to sent to the factories. They should be spending their childhood having fun in the sunshine and being educated so they have a chance of a bright future.
Deletemichaelxiao
821
1)i think that child labor might be appropriate in some situations.for example,if your family is struggling to get money to buy food to survive, then you could make your child work as well so you could make enough money to keep your family from starving to death.therefor, child labor might be appropriate in some situations.
ReplyDeleteGIORGI KANTROSHVILI 821
Child labor is not appropriate in any circumstances because its not right to give jobs to children of ages 10 because they need to have fun and finish school. If the parents of the child are alcohol addicts and only use the money earn and wasted on alcohol.The child would have to depend on they're parents or they could chose to work and try to earn money for food.
ReplyDeleteMario Sotomayor 821
i disagree with you because the child need to work to get money to support the family, the need the money even the factories is bad for them
Deletejane zheng 821
1) The child labor is not appropriate in some situation because the children are losing their child hood in the dangerous factories. The children are suppose to have fun in the sunshine with their friends. Children should not be working in factories because the factories would be dangerous and the children didn't master all the skills that they need to work in the factory, which is extreme for the child health concern.
ReplyDelete2) The elements of childhood we attempted to protect when we regulate child labor is to have the children to attend school instead of working in factories. Working in factories is be very dangerous that they may cause health problems and other serious injuries. But attending school, the children will get educated and will have a bright future that is better than spending the whole childhood in the dangerous factories. Furthermore, the children are working from age 7-14 which is a time they are at school getting educated instead of working in the non happy environment.
michael xiao 821
I disagree with you on the first parts because if the children didn't go work, he would die of starvation. But I agree about the parts where children lose education because of child labor.
Delete-Alan Lin Class 821
I agree with you
Deletebut Alan, they shouldnt be starving because the parents should work hard enough so that the children don't need to work so hard at such a age.
Deletemichael xiao
821
I agree with because they should focus on their education instead of working and like you said they will have a brighter future. :)
DeleteMario Sotomayor 821
I disagree with you because children did it to support their family from starvation. Also if they didn't go to work they wouldn't get the experience from the hard work their parents did before to support them. Jarif Sarder 821
Deleteyes .child labor is allow in some cases. Sometime parent need the money. So they made the child go to work in factory. But some parent are greedy and make them go to work in the factory. They dont care about their safty of their chilren. They have no love for their kids
ReplyDeleteChild sould not go to work but they have their education. A kid with out their education will not sucessful in life. Kids should not go to work because they are precious. They can take care of you When they grow up. It can also create heath problem for kids. These can effect their future life! Gavin zhang 821
I agree that children shouldnt go to work however in some situation when they are willing to go to work and their family needs the extra money it is ok. -Ryan Jiang 821
Delete#1 Child labor is never appropriate in all situations because child are children they need to live there lives and be free as a kid and learn how the world works not by working at a factory
ReplyDelete#2 As a child we need to protect our imagination because thats the reason why we have ideas in the first place but if children weren't able to think of ideas then there aren't able to help how america came to be and the rights are very different because children don't have much freedom as a grown person
Kernan kong 821
but what if the parents need money and they dont have enough help to do that how would a child enjoy their childhood if they always poor children need to try to help their parents even if it scafires their childhood by hasan tasnemul
DeleteWhat if the children family have very little money? The child have to work in order to supported and earn money for the family. And what do you mean when you says that children don't have much freedom as adult? Please explain.
Delete-Alan Lin 821
1.i think child labor is apporitate if the work is safe and pays decent money because children are lazy and they need exercise need to do something with theirlife also if the family is in desperate need in money having that extra money is nice
ReplyDelete2.we are trying to protect child freetime and have fun and also education so when tey grow up they could get better jobs human right differ from child rights because child rights are to have a good education and human rights are good payed decent jobs
byHasanTasnemul
1.In some situation child labor is appropriate due to families being poor so they need their children to help earn money to provide for the family. However sometimes when families just want their children to work in factories it isnt fair.
ReplyDelete2.When you regulate child labor it makes the children be able to get an education so they can get a better job.Childrens rights differ from general human rights because the children have less say but they are protected more since they are the future generation.
-Ryan Jiang 821
I agree with #1 because well children need to help out but you said its unfair its unfair to what,if the child was not in a factory and was home all day what would the family do to help sustain them
DeleteKernan kong 821
1) child labor isnt okay in any situation because children shouldnt be froced to work. they should have a choiceto work at their own will.
ReplyDelete2) we shouldnt put stress on kids. we should rpotect their childhood because they need to have some fun. a childs rights differs from a adult life by havong a choice. they cant be forced or hurt because they need a childhood
@_heemadrie_
Follow^^^
82111111111
You need to put more detail as to why you feel that way and what we are trying to protect
Deletei disagree with the first answer beacuse they should do some chores around their homes. i totally dont understand question 2 because what do you mean by they cant be forced or hurt because they need childhood. i disagree because they werent forced all the time they worked for money.
Delete-javohir sharifov 821
Child labor can be appropriate at home for chores but not in actualltough labor children can get hurt. when we regulated child labor we protected the kids fun life and so thye would have a normal life. children are younger so they can't do they jobs of other humans they aren'tas strong or as smart.
ReplyDelete-javohir sharifov 821
I am not totally sure that you have answered the prompts. You need to think a bit deeper into the issue
Deletei really personally think that child labor is appropriate when the child personally agrees on what to do to deserve/ get money in many ways. when people used child labor, those child lose there childhood and education plus fun experiences. Elizabeth Torres 821
ReplyDelete1.Yes,I think child labor is appropriate in some situations because some parent can't support the family so children have to go to work in order to support the family.
ReplyDelete2.The elements of a childhood that we are attempting to protect when we regulate child labor is if the child really needs to go to work to support the family,then that child shouldn't do some dangerous jobs they should do the easy and safe jobs.The right of a child differ from general human right because back then child at a young age can go to work but right now child can only go to work at the age of 18.
-MeiZhenMei 821
1)I think child labor is appropriate in some situation because long ago people are poor so children need money to support family by working in factories because it there only job.
ReplyDelete2)The elements of childhood we attempted to protect when we regulated child labor is to let children go to school and learn and can be free.In addition, they can also have a lot of friend at school.They also can play outside while their parent are doing something at home like cooking.Children also should be happy everyday.The right of child is differ from general human right is because they earn less money than adult they can't be against adult and they have to listen to adult.In conclusion,I thin children and adult should be the same because they are all human.
-Si Ting Chen 821
1)I think child labor is appropriate in some situations because if they only have one parent or their parent don't earn enough money to support the family.In that situation the children can help earn some money so they can survive.
ReplyDelete2)The elements of childhood we attempted to protect when we regulate child labor is the children should go to school to learn and have free time to go play with friends.Working in factories cause children to not talk to anyone,they just do work.Having the children get educated mean they can have a better life.
-Kanghao Lin 821
i disagree with you because if the family only have 1 parents, then why don't the parent go find their friends or other members to support them instead of having their children to work in such a dangerous condition. The parent should not force their children to work but to have them get educated to have a bright future.
Deletemichael xiao 821
a add on to question 2 .The right differ from adult to children because they are younger and the choice are made by their parent not the children so they need to be protected.
Delete-Kanghao Lin 822
Yes it is appropriate because children are doing it to support their family. They do it so there family don't starve to death and die. That's why it is appropriate in some situations. 2. The way there rights differ is children can do things general humans can't do and general humans have more rights and respect. Jarif Sarder 821
ReplyDelete1.Child labor is never good in any situation or appropriate. Children should never work extreme amounts of work at a young age. They arent capable of doing hard work for 12+ hours a day.
ReplyDelete2.The main component i think that were trying to protect is a kids enjoyment and fun. The main reason for a kid is to have fun and play, so i think most people are trying to protect that element
Adnan Pasha 821
1)yes child labor is appropriate for some situations including farm work and helping the family.since child labor is based on making money to be able to feed the family since the parents are not able to make enough to feed the family
ReplyDelete2)the elements of childhood we are trying to protect are their life and the fact that they can go to school.the rights of children differ from the rights of adults since children are young and adults are able to do things that children cant like drinking for example another example would be driving. william 821
Child labor should be decided by the children themselves, whether they should be doing it.We are trying to protect children and their childhood because the are working at a young age;their childhood had been taken away from them.Children are the future to america and the next generation.That's why it is important to protect children from child labor.
ReplyDeleteTina Lu 821
To think child labor is appropriate in an emergency situation is a, yes, however it depend on he/she's respond. I believe there show be a time when everybody need help from others in different ways. Base in the same text " It was initially used to aid the family in farm work and then in factories to speed up production and as a way for factory owners to save money".
ReplyDelete2) Taking considering of child labor, i believe people use this kids like slaves (most likely). i think kids should have a fun childhood, mostly play around or studying. Young human need to learn more about the world, they aren't tools or etc.
christine lu 821
2)the elements of childhood we are attempting to protect is the fun.for example, a child today goes outside and plays with him/her friends and enjoys themselves,however child labor took away this right and replaced it working 12-19 hours a day to make enough money to help their family out.in addition,the rights of a child differ from human general rights because a child plays around,acts irresponsible and foolish and plays outside with their friends and they have fun,however general human rights is to be responsible and mature and to go and work at a job.therefor,this is the elements of childhood we are attempting to protect against child labor and this is how child rights differ from general human rights
ReplyDeleteGIORGI KANTROSHVILI 821
1. I believe in some situations Child Labor is appropriate and some situations it isn't. The reason why Child Labor may be appropriate is because the children need to support their family by earning money from working in the factory. I also believe Child Labor is not appropriate because the children who work in the factory gets abused and hurt while working. They get abused almost for no reason. The children work for almost 12-19 hours a day and they don't get breaks which is very unfortunate.
ReplyDelete2. The elements of childhood we attempted to protect when we regulate child labor is that the children should go to school. They shouldn't be working all day with a low salary and no break, they need their education. While the children works in the factory they may get sick and have health issues. For instance the children may not have an bright future because of working in the factory for several hours.
Faizan 821
1.In some situation, child labor will be appropriate because sometimes child will have some problems in their house. They might have some money issues happening, their parents are not earning enough to support their family so they have to go to factories to earn more money so they can have enough food and have a place to shelter them self.
ReplyDelete2.The elements of childhood we attempted to protect when we regulate child labor is to let them go to school and get education. Working in factories has let a children having health issues and some deadly injuries. Instead of going to factories to work, they should go to school and have education. Having education helps them in their future life because once they have learn the skills that they have, they will know how to support them self.